Yeah, if you could post the saved game somewhere that would be great. If you got it in Scraptown, maybe there is a script controlling a character who is supposed to give you an item and the wrong item is called. (Although, the only item I can think of that is supposed to be given to the player character is a tool.) Did you talk to all the characters in Scraptown? Hmmm... if it was given to you in Scraptown, I would think you would have noticed it, though, as you would have been overloaded right away.