So the game doesnt need to be bad necessarily, it could be a game you think is good but the hype for it is way way over stated. Overrated: Bioshock- By no means a bad game, I actually like it quite a bit but System shock 2 and prey blow this title out of the water and this game didn't really deserve the scores it got. Deus Ex- Great game too, best PC game ever? No. If its individual mechanics like combat and stealth were more refined and less janky I would agree but as of now they kinda suck tbh. Underrated: Hyper Light Drifter- This game is a great combination of dark souls and zelda. Fucking love it and its a shame there isnt enough people who have played it. Prey-Bad marketing and the idiotic controversy over the name (like seriously since when was Prey 2006 a good game that must be preserved) this spiritual successor to system shock 2 is unfortunately underrated as fuck.