Ok
@Lexx got some bugs...
Dogmeat has this weird issue that his hp is 47/47 instead of 50/50 when recruited (using roboog version)
after going to dogmeat's character sheet his 47/47 hp turns to 47/50 hp.. totally weird...
this issue is just the basic proto as after lvlup the issue is gone.
Marcelles at crash house (owner of hotel in junktown) always spawns a shotgun on map reentering ( it works when you exit and enter the map, but not on save and reload on hotel map. always a brand new shotgun 800 free bottle caps plus 2 shotgun shells.
theese rewards seem lame considering one had acces to everything before getting to BoS.
Maybe it's time for a fresh look into this matter like the ability to actually get super sledge besides choosing between it and power armor in reward for save initiate quest.
Perhaps Mega Power fist, and super sledge for melee and unarmed, and something more fancy for the guns as Sniper Rifle is already obtainable from various sources (The Glow being one of them) Rocket launcher besides beeing obtainable form Jacob, Glow, and Gunrunners, is not a prime choice for certain builds (especialy with party), as for 'Loser' Pistol i don't even want to scratch the surface it's just plain wrong at this point of the game.
Some Super Mutants have Hilariously low Hit Points for example nuke guards have like a bazillion stimpacks and toughest weapons in game and only 49HP. they used to have like 140. as theyre sepose to be a challange to beat. other Super Mutants need revision as well. just too darn many have 49HP in both Military Base and Cathedral.
I've finished the game and this quest did not crossed out.