Per said:
Father Tully is down in the basement? Huh?
So that's NOT Tully in the train station basement? Oy. Here's how the quest worked for me:
--talked to Mizzus Wright, stopped pissing her off, got the quest
--went to the church, she wasn't there, looked up your guide, set PipBoy to 6am, she wasn't there, saved, reloaded, wasn't there, loaded earlier save, talked to Mizzus Wright, stopped pissing her off, got the quest, went to the church, she wasn't there
--went to the train station basement, there's only one person down there with the still and he has Tully's avatar (but then, who doesn't?) and all the dialog box says is "you see a man," so I do the business with the C4 and laugh my butt off when pseudo-Tully wanders all the way back across the room from where I pushed him to the exact spot where the C4 is and gets himself blown to bits
Is there another way it's supposed to work? Is Mrs. Wright supposed to come with you to the train station? (It's this kind of thing that encourages FO2 players to adopt a "kill 'em all, let God sort 'em out" mindset. I mean, seriously.)
I'm running the official 1.02 patch, my game is a store-bought US version, can provide computer specs if necessary.