cratchety ol joe
Mildly Dipped

This thread is also a little dig at the FO4 intro which I personally believe to be wildly inaccurate to how I perceive the pre-war fallout time divergent universe. I wasn't sure if this should be posted into the FO4 sub-forum, but I consider it to have a wider 'general' fallout discussion point, please bear with me 
I've brought this up so I can finally get some peace of mind, as it's been driving me crazy just how 40's/50's styled Bethesda has made the game.
Before I get going, I want to try and establish a few things I think are key.
1. Origin lore (cannon)
Things that are written into the game (items, concepts or otherwise) that set precedent to their being. Considered to be entirely internally consistent to the game world.
2. Loose cannon
Ideas contained within the same general concept of the world of Fallout but are tenuous at best or require some stretch of internal consistency to be considered as 'accurate to lore'.
3. Ret-con lore
Additional or contradictory 'things' that are (by current standards) to be considered as lore of the game world but are inconsistent with items of already established origin lore. For the purpose of this thread I will state I really hate ret-con and as such unless there is exceptional reason to accept it I will always define that origin lore trumps ret-con.
So with this in mind-
I propose that the into of FO4 (and indeed some of the FO3 pre-war concepts) are entirely wrong. Presenting the world as a 50's idyllic America, complete with cooky bubble-top cars and swaths of 'retro' detailing.
I would propose that the pre-war Fallout would be more like the early 80's but with a 50's flavour, much like fashion trend resurge from time to time.
I would further press that the world at large has access to technology and social identity similar to what we see in today's "real" world.
There are several concepts I want to drag up which I think reinforce my near-cyberpunk, 50's influenced alternate future.
Important details (lore)
Now a small tangent; FO1 was developed during the 80's and, as such it is reasonable that the development team had little to no way of accurately predicting the world as we have it now.
Some real-world concepts I must address:
Social changes in attitude and fashion
I find it implausible that dress and music fashion's have not altered in 110 years. (1950 - 2070) even in 'real-world' we have seen dramatic and continued wide-spread changes.
1940' - 50's Swing era
50's - 60's Rock era
60's - 70's bohemian
70's - 80's glam / punk
80's - 90's electro & new-age
90's - 00's the rise of 'emo' and scene
There are others but the point being that every decade has seen dramatic alterations in how the world at large lives it's social life. As such the entirely 40's/50's-esq opening of FO4 defies the norm of altering fashion. I would also like to argue against the detail that music, music never changes - except that it bloody well does! I despise that FO4 thrives on the swing-band of the 40's despite the fact there is probably a far greater selection of music available in the year 2077 than even I can imagine.
caveat
I would concede that as part of a social reform there 'could be' a resurgence of 50's revival for fashion etc, however I would see this as an influence of the modern culture and not a defined element of itself.
As such, fashion would have a 40's / 50's influence and the music might be similar to 'electro swing' (which was a literal real-world resurgence of 40's swing music but with modern theme)
This I would propose makes an internally consistent alternate world and to me (at least for now) I would consider it loose cannon.
Microprocessors
I can't remember where this came up but I saw a post that stated these had only just been introduced just prior to 'the war'
I find this to be a considerable ret-con that breaks a lot of essential origin lore, there are simply too many things in the world of Fallout 1 & 2 that demand highly advanced electronic components well beyond 'basic microprocessors'
As such I would strike this idea as a redundant ret-con to be dismissed.
Now, I need your thought and help.
Is my cyber-punk 80's / 50's retro-revival vision of 2077 accurate? What would you consider and why?

I've brought this up so I can finally get some peace of mind, as it's been driving me crazy just how 40's/50's styled Bethesda has made the game.
Before I get going, I want to try and establish a few things I think are key.
1. Origin lore (cannon)
Things that are written into the game (items, concepts or otherwise) that set precedent to their being. Considered to be entirely internally consistent to the game world.
2. Loose cannon
Ideas contained within the same general concept of the world of Fallout but are tenuous at best or require some stretch of internal consistency to be considered as 'accurate to lore'.
3. Ret-con lore
Additional or contradictory 'things' that are (by current standards) to be considered as lore of the game world but are inconsistent with items of already established origin lore. For the purpose of this thread I will state I really hate ret-con and as such unless there is exceptional reason to accept it I will always define that origin lore trumps ret-con.
So with this in mind-
I propose that the into of FO4 (and indeed some of the FO3 pre-war concepts) are entirely wrong. Presenting the world as a 50's idyllic America, complete with cooky bubble-top cars and swaths of 'retro' detailing.
I would propose that the pre-war Fallout would be more like the early 80's but with a 50's flavour, much like fashion trend resurge from time to time.
I would further press that the world at large has access to technology and social identity similar to what we see in today's "real" world.
There are several concepts I want to drag up which I think reinforce my near-cyberpunk, 50's influenced alternate future.
Important details (lore)
- We know that hand held two way radio's exist (they are a major plot device of FO1 & 2)
- this simple fact demands that microprocessors have been in existence for at least 30 years! from the point at which microprocessors were developed this would place the time into the 80's (more on microprocessors later)
- We know that robotic micro-surgery exists in FO1 & FO2.
- this demands that medical research as well as complex robotics exist to a level only achieved very recently in our own history.
- The oft discussed point of point of divergence arises, and one key element I see from lore is that 5.56 ammo exists.
- if weapons development can at least be 'guessed' to mimic the "real" world, this came about as part of a weapons development program introduced because of the war in Vietnam, so we can at least have an educated guess that this war has occurred and that puts time into the mid 70's
- There are other weapons and technology which demand that the timeline have reached at least into the 80's with technology that exists to prove development must have continued well into the year 2000.
Now a small tangent; FO1 was developed during the 80's and, as such it is reasonable that the development team had little to no way of accurately predicting the world as we have it now.
Some real-world concepts I must address:
Social changes in attitude and fashion
I find it implausible that dress and music fashion's have not altered in 110 years. (1950 - 2070) even in 'real-world' we have seen dramatic and continued wide-spread changes.
1940' - 50's Swing era
50's - 60's Rock era
60's - 70's bohemian
70's - 80's glam / punk
80's - 90's electro & new-age
90's - 00's the rise of 'emo' and scene
There are others but the point being that every decade has seen dramatic alterations in how the world at large lives it's social life. As such the entirely 40's/50's-esq opening of FO4 defies the norm of altering fashion. I would also like to argue against the detail that music, music never changes - except that it bloody well does! I despise that FO4 thrives on the swing-band of the 40's despite the fact there is probably a far greater selection of music available in the year 2077 than even I can imagine.
caveat
I would concede that as part of a social reform there 'could be' a resurgence of 50's revival for fashion etc, however I would see this as an influence of the modern culture and not a defined element of itself.
As such, fashion would have a 40's / 50's influence and the music might be similar to 'electro swing' (which was a literal real-world resurgence of 40's swing music but with modern theme)
This I would propose makes an internally consistent alternate world and to me (at least for now) I would consider it loose cannon.
Microprocessors
I can't remember where this came up but I saw a post that stated these had only just been introduced just prior to 'the war'
I find this to be a considerable ret-con that breaks a lot of essential origin lore, there are simply too many things in the world of Fallout 1 & 2 that demand highly advanced electronic components well beyond 'basic microprocessors'
As such I would strike this idea as a redundant ret-con to be dismissed.
Now, I need your thought and help.
Is my cyber-punk 80's / 50's retro-revival vision of 2077 accurate? What would you consider and why?
Last edited: