Wex said:
Suaside, you imply that everything you do in life is caused by the fear of death? I... I really can't understand your line of reasoning.
well, greatly, yes. since our time is limited, we feel the need for advancement (in all sorts of things). if you knew you would live forever, there would be no pressure whatsoever. no urge to perform, no urge to advance, no urge to be active and hence no urge to actually live really.
our actions are primarily fueled by the will to fulfil primary needs: food, shelter, and so on... if we were immortal, those very concepts would mean nothing to us.
Wex said:
Why would afterlife be unlikely anyway? Eighty-five percent of people believe in some kind of it, would you try to explain where they err?
what exactly are their arguments? "god told me", "some guy says he heard god say so", "some guy wrote a book about what god told him", "i had a near death experience and i saw a blinding light at the end of the tunnel!", and so on and so forth. well, excuse me if i'm not quite convinced.
Wex said:
And what's the point of living if death is final?
what's the point in living if there is no real death?
i live mostly to have fun and help my family & friends, so that their lives can be fun too.
and because death isn't really appealing to tell you the truth, so i dont have much of a choice there.
Wex said:
Everything I did, every mark I made in people's lives, every challenge I coped with, every love, every tear, every smile, every hope, everything I came through that made me who I am is for naught?
you enjoyed it, didn't you? then it wasn't really for naught from my point of view.
building a sandcastle seems futile to your convictions then, as it will surely be destroyed, be it by the waves or by the rain. it's all for naught, but it's fun and somewhat challenging.
Wex said:
I will die, and I will be forgotten. People around me will die and eventually be forgotten. Nothing will remain in the end.
nuthin' but recycled molecules...
Wex said:
How can you live in such doomed world? If you truly believe death's the end, then, in a sense, you already are truly dead.
dead & doomed? perhaps, but it seems i'm more alive than you are. while you live your life towards the afterlife, i live my life now unbound by any restrictive code of morals enforced on me by some belief. i only follow my own morals, not someone elses.
Wex said:
If you chose not to believe in something greater, in immortal essence of a human being, in afterlife, and if your world really makes sense as such, that's your call. I couldn't bear to live with no hope.
no hope? i hope to be healthy, i hope to live a good life, i hope my friends lead a good life. what else do you need? some bonus incentive in the afterlife? "suicide now, kill as many people as possible and gain a bonus of 40 maidens! limited time offer! act now!"
Wex said:
(Moreover, that belief implies that everything around us arose from chance. How do you explain the genesis of life? Or intelligence? Or love? Are they all just... coincidences? Accidental rearrangement of molecules? Really.
)
a cosmic brainfart if you wish.
of course, i do not say i know how the galaxy was formed or how life came to be, but i doubt there was any god or conscious entity that orchestrated it.
Wex said:
If you chose to believe in such, you will come to terms with death. It is not the end, it is nothing to be afraid of. (Else, as I said, there would be no point in life, even no point in bearing children: in a sense, you condemn them to death as soon as they are conceived. Talk about twisted perspective...) Death is as natural as birth is.
of course, but why should i be afraid of disappearing entirely once my life is over? why should i feel sorry for my children if they disappear likewise after a fulfilling life?
to me the concept of life after death you find in nearly all religions seems to be a simple tool to ingrain a certain moral standard. if you life by those standards, you get to eat desserts with golden spoons all day, or shag 40 virgins all night. if you fuck up & tell them to sod off, you will forever burn in eternal damnation! this applies to heaven & hell, as well to reincarnation & so on and so forth.
these things are merely a set of morals or ethics that are reinforced with a reward or a punishment. it also causes people to accept adverse conditions under the guise that everything will be ok, the afterlife will repay you for your suffering.
i've got this little theory that both the bible and koran were written by very smart philosophers who sought to imprint those morals (who are in fact a lot like laws) and give people hope. nothing less, nothing more.
you'll notice that only very few religions brake away from those stereotypes.
anyhow, is there a god? doubt it. does it matter in the end? not really... just live a good life by your own values & morals and try to help the people you can. if thats not good enough for any god out there, then tough luck for him. (if i go to hell for this, he sure is one pathetic little sack o' shit...)