Troika vs. Silver Style

Which company should make Fallout 3?

  • Total voters
    155
welsh

welsh

Junkmaster
Assuming there is a chance that Fallout 3 is ever made-

If it were a choice between these two companies, which would you prefer to develop Fallout 3? Why?
 
Troika because Tim Cain founded it along with some other original FO1/2 developers. If Troika makes FO3 then we will surely have a game with the true FO spirit :)
 
So how would you judge the differences between Troika and Silver Style.

So far, it seems quite a few people have been disappointed with Troika so far.
 
welsh said:
So how would you judge the differences between Troika and Silver Style.
Click to expand...

I really don't know SS at all and, as I said, Troika includes ex-FO devs.

So far, it seems quite a few people have been disappointed with Troika so far.
Click to expand...

Although it had its problems, i thought Arcanum was great in everything.
 
I looked at SS 's Fall , seems promising , but whatever people say , i for one enoyed Arcanum a lot and i still play it.
And since troika has some former members of the fallout team , they might do better then SS.
 
Troika. You're talking to this forum's leading Troika fanboy. If you read my rants defending ToEE and Arcanum on the ol' Troika Board, you'd understand.

Without trying to get too long winded, I'll give some reasons. First off, for obvious reasons, it's got Tim Cain, Leon Boyarsky, and Jason Anderson, the "three leading principals" of their past games. Then they've got experience in the industry. And, if Vampires does well, they'll also have a bigger budget than what was scene in Arcanum and ToEE.

I haven't seen much of Silver Style's work. I'll reserve judgment until I've played The Fall.
 
We're talking Fallout 3 here. Who cares if gameplay is repetitive and bugs are a-plenty. Troika is one of the best when it comes to shaping original and compelling game worlds, and that's what I'm really looking forward to in Fallout 3.
 
Troika. Hands down. It´s been already explained why. Also, I think the Fall looks somewhat "odd". Thumbs up for both anyways.
 
The reason is obvious - but Troika.
It's just that SS are a young company and have no experience and Troika has xp.
Anyway I think that neither WILL make Fo3
 
You should have added an option like "the old black isle" cause that's who really should be making the game. Troika's great, but it looks like they've already started making a post-apoc game and silver style, well, is too young a company, and what i've seen of their games isn't impressive, to say the least.
 
Francisco M L S G S said:
Troika because Tim Cain founded it along with some other original FO1/2 developers.
Click to expand...

Just saying; the original Fallout guys in Troika weren't working on BIS' Van Buren either, and nobody was saying "Troika should do Fallout 3, not BIS!", despite the fact that the crew working on VB was mostly non-Fallout related, especially after JE left. But that's just label obsession, n'est pas?

The whole "worked on previous Fallout games" never mattered to me, so I'm not riding the whole Troika-hype.
 
Kharn said:
Just saying; the original Fallout guys in Troika weren't working on BIS' Van Buren either, and nobody was saying "Troika should do Fallout 3, not BIS!", despite the fact that the crew working on VB was mostly non-Fallout related, especially after JE left.
Click to expand...

Wrong.
 
Well then, count out for us who of them worked on Fallout 1, or did more than superficial "I did a bit on the path"-work on Fallout 2.
Click to expand...
Chris Jones was a lead programmer on FO1 and 2. Scott Everts and John Deiley were designers on FO2 (Deiley did something on FO1 too, according to the official site).

Anyway, I choose Troika for obvious reasons.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top