GameInformer is fucking retarded.
There are so many face-palmingly bad statements in this. Here's the list.
1. Predators being stealthy is bad- What in the fu... I assume he's never seen the original, in which the Predator is cloaked until the very end.
2. Aliens crawling on walls is disorienting- I do agree it takes getting used to, but after a few matches, you get it down. I assume this guy didn't and felt very butthurt about it.
3. The flashlight is dim- "Gosh, what are they trying to do? Create a scary atmosphere by limiting your sight range? I never saw that in the movies."
4. The motion tracker is loud- Wasn't this something the original game was praised for? Ya know, the loud beeping was supposed to scare the fuck out of you because you knew 5 Xenos were going to claw your fucking face off?
5. Only mentions Deathmatch- "Oh dear! I spent so much time failing in the Alien campaign that I can only play 1 match before I have to type this up! Uhhh, Deathmatch! Alright, let's play this and base the entire review off the single-player."
6. Lighting is bad- "Gosh, it sure is dark without any bloom or HDR. Minus -.5 points."
7. Game is listed as being for consoles only, despite a PC version existing- This is just plain dumb. I need not say anything about this.
8. Limited Melee combat in Predator campaign- What is this, Street Fighter? You are not going to punch out an acid-spewing abomination all the time.
He also mentions linearity (Call of Duty MW 2 was ultra linear and it got a 9.75), and AI problems (coming from the guys who praised Oblivion for it's wonderful AI). I assume Rebellion forgot to give GI advertising money and they got mad over it.