kyojinmaru said:
Surf Solar said:
The game can have the best writing imaginable, it would still suck if it has crappy gameplay, which coincidentally all Bethesda games do posess.
So everything must be isometric and turn based?, man, I know you must stand in your beth hating role, but Skyrim's gameplay is far from bad.
No, its not that at all.
Isometric is a game design choice, especially suited for 'tactical rpg's, but what some really liked was indeed the pause-turn based. Turn based was absolutely crucial, at least for me - to take a perspective on the action, strategize, and order my followers around. However, FOT added three types of combat choices -> Continuous Turn-Based, Individual Turn-Based, and Squad Turn-based.
No one can pretend that trying to do "tactics" in FO3, especially with followers, is not a pain in the ass, because it is.
In Skyrim, even with mods, trying to do "tactics" with your followers is also a pain in the ass - the game is suited for what it is, an Elder Scrolls specific game type perspective for Elder Scrolls, the player is where it is best.
Is Skyrim bad to some? Maybe. But I love it for what it is, an Elder Scrolls game-type made for the first perspective - although I do play it with mods. Also there is no consequence for my followers dying, because they merely faint - the game is balanced around the death of the player, rather than consequences for death of followers.
I want
choices for game-play type rather than playing Elder Scroll game mechanics in a Fallout game, with Fallout SPECIAL shoved into it. That is the main issue for me.
Imagine if they actually added gameplay types in the new 'first person' style Fallout games. One where you could play in Continuous First/Third Person or Continuous First/Third Person - Paused (both available in FO3/NV), with an additional Top-Down Tactical-Pause in both continuous or turn-based pause. Perhaps it would be a lot of work, but that's what I dream for the future of Fallout games. Hell, add the ability to select your followers from the UI on the top-left so you can order followers on the fly rather than walking up to them, which is so damn annoying in FO3/NV.
That's my biggest gripe, mainly since it is entirely possible to do even 3PV with additional gametype options such as Top-Down Esque with Tactical-Pause-Like (AKA, Dragon Age). Whether that is possible on Gamebryo is beyond my knowledge, but it doesn't seem to be.