krysalist said:
I mean, I wanted them to fail, just like I wanted Rockstar to fail at bringing GTA from a top-down perspective, to a 3D openworld. I just wanted to hang on to the past, to my positive memories of the old games, and not have to contend with game developers prancing on my old favorites like bedbugs on my posturpedic.
I know people may not agree with me and 3D GTA series actually worked well in commercial level, I played GTA IV in PS3 and after 1-2 days I was sure that the game is utterly rubbish, and totally stupid.
I tried to play other GTA 3D titles due to massive success, and same results for me.
Exact same thing happened with titles such as Postal and Worms World Party. Have you played Postal 3D, it's terrible, but original postal was an awesomely fun game.
I know it's not a good example but Prince of Persia series are executed perfectly, 3D great platform gaming, I'm not fan of the series but I can see the great implementation and great re-branding.
Bethesda did an easy choice, "Here is the engine, here is the world, everyone loves 3D shooters, we already did a FP RPG called Oblivion even though it sucked so bad there are lots of weird people who loved it, so let's do it in the same way."
They did and worked. It's not re-branding they used their own resources, and lemme tell you Fallout 4 will be. Exactly same with some interface tweaks, slightly better graphics and slightly better AI. Since people buying it, why bother to make it even better, just burn money to do marketing, there are lots of players out there I'm sure someone will like it.
P.S. I liked Fallout 3 and I do play it, however I hated 3D (it's not Bethesda's fallout), I hated graphics (IMHO it looks rubbish, look at all AAA titles in 2008, and that's enough to figure out), I hated FPS bit of it, I hated VATS, I hated that I have to use VATS. Overall it could have been so much better, and I'm pissed to Bethesda because now we won't get original Fallout back ever! They got the IP and they fu**ed it.
My only hope is a good company will buy the rights for Pocket PC, PSP, iPhone etc. and will make an isometric old school Fallout. (dreaming...)