DarkCorp
So Old I'm Losing Radiation Signs
That was a general post.
I didn't handwave shit, I merely ignore whatever the hell you said and type in reply of what I think you will say by basing off the idea that I am responding to a moron.
Yeah, they were trotskyist, still a little weird to me though because it was a time of war.The POUM were Trotskyist I think, which explains Soviet hostility to them
Communism is the complete abolition of state, and class, so I would hardly call it contradictory. We may colloquially refer to the USSR as communism, but we've never gotten to that point (and I don't think we will), and they got stuck in the state socialist mire and either failed there or started liberalizing markets, either due to corruption, economic failure, shift in public desire, or the want to westernize.The 1st among equals. this is Anarchist Communism after all, which itself is a hypocritical and contradictory terminology.
Dude, I never said it would work, hence the "(I don't think we will)" part.But how does one 'enforce', the communist utopia? Someone had to draft the laws and someone has to enforce the laws.
Even the most remote and primitive tribes has some kind of leadership caste, which ruins the whole idea of it bring anarcho commie.
But how does one 'enforce', the communist utopia? Someone had to draft the laws and someone has to enforce the laws.
Anarchist means no laws or rules.
Dawg, all i said is that Anarcho Communism is not contradictory because the meaning of communism is a stateless classless society and also added on that No society will likely ever reach that point in development, because, every society has had a state, and/or class. No one is saying "yeah that wasn't real socialism" because that's stupid. It's important to understand ideological distinction between the 2.Homeslice just No True Scottsman'd Communism. Brah must be the Pope of Commies if he can dictate what a real one is.
1. That's not at all what Anarchism means, the original latin means "without rulers" however the ideological notion is "no unjustified rulers or hierarchy" meaning a hierarchy must justify itself, the community democatically decides on rulers and rules for the community and as such is enforced by the community it self (not arguing that it would work, but you have zero understanding of what anarchism as a political philosophy means.How are the two systems NOT contradictory when even, as you say, we talk about it in a purely ideological sense.
Anarchist means no laws or rules. Communism as an idea, is meant to operate on a very specific, while small, set of rules. The rule is each to his own need.
As you point out, the fact that these groups agree or work as 'allies', is proof at some level of organisation or order.
Dawg, all i said is that Anarcho Communism is not contradictory because the meaning of communism is a stateless classless society
The Majority of the population is Majority of the population, and that is the consequence of direct democracy. The arguments I've seen is ensuring the minority is armed and has the ability to defend themselves from oppression of the majority. (which would most likely fail due to the majority having the raw numbers advantage.)Even if we go your route, is not the group who gets their wishes fulfilled over the group that doesn't constitute a ruling caste or at the very least, a majority?
Following that route, do we not inevitably arrive at the problem of tyranny by majority?
The world of the marxists will be shocked that some random jagov on a fan site for a FPS game with shitty graphics just redefined all of marxist theory.
there we go again. It wasn't real communism because I said so even though they called themselves communists, it didn't count.You are genuinely retarded dude, I'm sorry.
I like how I said that "Socialism has been tried and failed" and then links a video saying "wasn't real socialism" lmfao fucking moron.
You are genuinely retarded dude, I'm sorry.
I like how I said that "Socialism has been tried and failed" and then links a video saying "wasn't real socialism" lmfao fucking moron.
The world of the marxists will be shocked that some random jagov on a fan site for a FPS game with shitty graphics just redefined all of marxist theory.
a fan site for a FPS game with shitty graphics