Took played a lot of Fallout 3, and now read most of the guide and I am trying out a new build. now that I know a lot more about the game there really isn't a decision in how to play, only combat. Basically my new build and leveling perks are as such: charisma 1, fuck child at heart, and am still trying to figure out if there are any Unique weapons from Lawbringer/contract killer, guide says no, but guide also says you can not rig the election in Republic of dave, which i did, and in the walkthrough didn't mention the lucky eightball from big town (though it was in the appendix). But I'll have a better guide out for everyone within a day or 2.
Basically
S 5 or 6
P 3
E 7
C 1
I 9 or 10
A 9
L 5 or 6
Get perception up to 4 at lvl 2 with IT, get ant sight to get it to 5, go to capital of dave to get it to 6 with bobblehead
Charisma is worthless doesn't change anyones opinion of you, only karma and the speech options you choose and actions you do. Even speech options don't change anyone much.
Luck only 5 because, Ranger Battle Armor you get via a quest gives you luck +1, also ap 5 small guns 10 and 39 DR AKA best armor in game and you can get it pretty quick, pick the armor because you can steal the "2 of a kind" minigun from Baker called Eugene (its 2 of a kind because you get pick this as quest reward and steal one. Starts at Museum of history from a human, Reily. Lucky Shades plus 1 luck (haven't found where to get these only that they are in the appendix of unique items), Bobblehead plus 1 luck. And 3 dogs headband gives you 1 luck too. That = 10 plus finesse is 5 plus vats is 15% and ninja if you go melee = 45% crital chance and all guns and weapons give 1-4 crit. Answer snidely to all of the wasteland guide book questions and do all the optional objectives and that is 3 more crit. Thats anywhere from 49% to 52% crit chance melee. And 34-37 ranged.
havent tested out but quick run down of what i think im going to suggest perkwise for a combat character (because there really is no other option to play whole game with) on Hard difficulty.
BW, IT perception, Educated, Comprehension, Bloodymess (yes i know you hate me, but 5% extra dmg), Toughness, Scrounger, Commando, Finesse, Strong back, Sniper, Pyro (flamer is nice versus brutes and masters), Lawbringer (trying to read around see if anyone got unique anything out of this) Cyborg (with this and toughness that is 20% Dr with is useful at hard and very hard difficulty) Action boy, better critticals, and for 18 and 19 pick between Tag/Silent Runner/Life giver/Demo exper and for 20 Grim Reaper.
Then later I will make a melee guide.
Edit: Only way to get 3 dogs head wrap is to kill him, if you don't want to do that take a point from intelligence and put it in luck. Then make sure to get to Rivit city ASAP to get the INT bobble head.
And the lucky shades are on some manquin somewhere just google "lucky shades" and "the vault"