AskWazzup
Sonny, I Watched the Vault Bein' Built!
I dunno, I kind of agree with him on most points about the gameplay; I haven't played it on the hardest difficulties, but on normal the AI is pretty unintelligent, most classes are lackluster and a lot of stats only have minor impacts on the game.
Which rpg has intelligent AI? To my experience, probably all the top ones are hovering roughly at the same point~. At least you can't kite the ones in POE for easy kills and if you attack one, the others neaby are usually alerted too. While mobs like the ghosts and Gŵla with their teleport and stun abilities can change the dynamic of a fight at all times, so you usually have to make adjustments. The lack of different skills and abilities are of course a mark on this game as opposed to DnD games with a mature system, but it's not dramatic and i had vastly different combat approaches with my main being a thief and a party concentrated on meele and then a cypher with a party concentrated on rifles.
I have only tried normal with trial of iron and while it didn't seem very hard, i did not finish that playthrough (i made a mistake entering lightower without adequate cold resistance). But on hard i had plenty of very hard fights throughout the game, as not are enemies tougher, there are also more of them.
Either way, I loved the game for its narrative and the characters I've come up with as a result. I really like the background-building aspect, it helps you immerse yourself in the world.
I really enjoyed the story and the dialogue, can't remember one time (off the top of my head) that it felt cheesy or out of place. The culmination was pretty unexpected in a good way.