I think Thomas Jane looks better if you're trying to depict him as the Punisher would look in real life. Ray Stevenson looks better if you're trying to give him a look that's more accurate to the comics. Jane was believable, Stevenson has a look that screams comic book over-the-top muscle head. I respect him as an actor and I think he can pull it off. They're both good choices for different reasons.
While it could have been better, I actually liked the original. Too many movie heroes finish the villain with a quick gunshot to the head. That's too damn merciful, this guy has been torturing puppies for 90 minutes, and then when he's finally offed it's so quick he doesn't even realize he's been killed. I wanna see the villain suffer, I want him to know he's been defeated and realize that fucking with the hero was a huge mistake. I liked the Punisher because he actually PUNISHED the villain and then gave him a humiliating death that let him know who's in charge now. I find that satisfying overall.
Still, it could have had more action. Though the new one looks like it will have more it doesn't show us much. The whole chandelier thing strikes me as a bit cheesy and is my biggest concern about the quality of this movie.
While it could have been better, I actually liked the original. Too many movie heroes finish the villain with a quick gunshot to the head. That's too damn merciful, this guy has been torturing puppies for 90 minutes, and then when he's finally offed it's so quick he doesn't even realize he's been killed. I wanna see the villain suffer, I want him to know he's been defeated and realize that fucking with the hero was a huge mistake. I liked the Punisher because he actually PUNISHED the villain and then gave him a humiliating death that let him know who's in charge now. I find that satisfying overall.
Still, it could have had more action. Though the new one looks like it will have more it doesn't show us much. The whole chandelier thing strikes me as a bit cheesy and is my biggest concern about the quality of this movie.