Yeah, it would work better as a reputation penalty, people wanting to do less with you because you eat people than because some force that observes good and evil judges you and somehow makes other people aware of it.
[Bishop];4044075 said:Seeing the Brotherhood of Steel ONLY being mentioned in the next Fallout game would be disappointing. Most of the factions i've read just now from looking at the fellow member's posts sound like Wasteland factions. I'm sure you realize that there is a cyborg thing going on in the Commonwealth or "Up north" in the east coast. I'm sure the next installment will be pretty epic, here's hoping everyone can see what made the modern generation of Fallout lovers, the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout 3,the NCR in New Vegas, the way they introduce those two factions in the up-to date version of Fallout series is pretty amazing. Then again it pretty much scratched off the isolationism from the original Fallout games,the ideas you guys make are cool though. How do i conclude? I'm not tired of these "old" factions, and this is my opinion.
[Bishop];4044075 said:Seeing the Brotherhood of Steel ONLY being mentioned in the next Fallout game would be disappointing. Most of the factions i've read just now from looking at the fellow member's posts sound like Wasteland factions. I'm sure you realize that there is a cyborg thing going on in the Commonwealth or "Up north" in the east coast. I'm sure the next installment will be pretty epic, here's hoping everyone can see what made the modern generation of Fallout lovers, the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout 3,the NCR in New Vegas, the way they introduce those two factions in the up-to date version of Fallout series is pretty amazing. Then again it pretty much scratched off the isolationism from the original Fallout games,the ideas you guys make are cool though. How do i conclude? I'm not tired of these "old" factions, and this is my opinion.
As long as they don't shoehorn in the BoS in and if they give them an actual purpose in the plot. Heck, maybe they could expand on the CW BoS's history and give more insight to them. Not the Enclave though, their send-off in New Vegas should be the perfect end to the organisation.
I'm conflicted about cutting Karma entirely (for admittedly stodgy reasons-- it's been more or less broken from the start, but it's also been there from the start), but I think you're spot-on about religious/ideological donations not effecting it. Rather than a temporary skill/stat bump to your character, though, I think the benefits should be more realistic and concrete-- a Reputation boost from the faction you're donating to, as well as perhaps benefits from or within that faction. Ideally, it'd be nice to see the accumulated total of your donations actually helping the church or organization spread within the game world and/or advance its aims, but even New Vegas didn't put in that much elbow grease, so I'm not holding my breath as far as seeing it in the franchise proper anytime soon.