Walpknut
This ghoul has seen it all

"Failing" the quest by killing everyone still gives you a different ending and Manny reacts like you completed the quest.
Yeah, I wouldn't fault the mission for that. It still had consequences.
I didn't know that you could do it all in one trip. I thought that Rad guy at the facility wouldn't spawn if you chose Gibson first or her dialogue wouldn't be there if you chose the other, but I guess I was wrong. Still, I find Come Fly With Me more tedious than Return to Sender probably because CFWM all takes place in pretty much one big facility and it gets kinda repetitive to me to see the same places over and over again though that's only really a problem if you do the quest all in one go like I do. RtS lets me travel around the Mojave which varies up the scenery.
Come fly with me is the best early game side quest in my opinion.
Legit question: Are we seriously going to have this same damn dog coincidentally named dog meat in every damn future Fallout release by Bethesda?
Come fly with me is the best early game side quest in my opinion. It supports pacifist builds and there are a lot of phases on it.
The worst early game sidequest is "Can you find it in your heart?" as it is not only a simplistic kill monster quest but you are supposedly "clearing" a zone you had to go through to get to the Outpost in the first place and you didn't find the Ants untilyou started the quest. Only reason to do it is for the AP 5.56mm ammo, the service rifle and caravan lunches that they reward you with.
See that's interesting because come fly with me might be my least favorite quest, I hated having to send those ghouls into space. I wanted a way to turn those rockets and the whole facility for that matter over to NCR, Mr House, the brotherhood or something like that. Just sending them to the moon to most likely die is just a huge waste of technology.
Well, the NCR isn't going to want it since they're more focused on the war with Caesar and a space program isn't going to help there. The Mojave brotherhood isn't going to want it because they're barely hanging on for survival and it's not going to help them much. Assuming Mr. Bright's calculations are correct, and the radiation involved in the launch is going to kill anybody who isn't a ghoul, House isn't going to want it because he'd presumably prefer to colonize space in a manner that does not doom the human race (ghouls, after all, are sterile) and would probably not want to use 200 year old rockets anyway. That's even considering that the ghouls aren't going to be happy to give away their rockets, as it's a holy mission for them (and they're probably the only people who know how to make this work at the time of the quest taking place.)
But we can be reasonably confident the ghouls knew what they were doing, since in the ending slide for Novac they return from their pilgrimage to help out Novac against the Legion.
The "these people are dumb and crazy" ending for that quest involves getting 5 boxes of sugar bombs.