Do you know what irony means, like how you know what a Lobotomy is?
I just staed what it's been stated in the game. You are trying to build a bridge with clouds.
Considering that you never acknowledged getting any of the facts wrong, despite being corrected with quotes repeatedly, yes I do know what irony is. I might also add that you've spent more time trying to insult me than making actual points, most of which you just keep repeating ad naseum.
I've addressed that real lobotomies and Fallout lobotomies are not the same thing. Why you think repeating refuted points constitutes an argument is beyond me.
Because if all your arguments are "What if the characters are wrong and I am right?" or ignoring the point that nobody mentions Christine getting her brain removed and instead focus on wether or not she knows the word Lobotomite I don't think you really know how to formulate an argument.
"
If." -Leonidas of Sparta
Also, who would tell us that her brain had been removed? Which character would know that?
Nobody says her brain wasn't removed. Nobody says anything other than lobotomies are being done forcefully on people entering the Big Empty. Nobody says there is something else being created by stuffing electronics into peoples skulls, that results in the same scars. Nobody indicates that the medical center didn't also invent lobotomites, as would be most logical. Nobody says she had a "botched implant surgery" that Ulysses interupted except you.
"They would have eventually found a way" =/= They already found a way and Christine used it. Specially when nothing points to this.
Not an actual quote, and also not my argument.
The courier can only leave the Big Mt as a Lobotomite through the use of Teleportation. Christine didn't have it and nothing states she did and the Transporter only gets made at the end of the Big MT quest. Thus, she has no way of leaving the Big MT without a brain in her head.
What's with the Random capitalizations?
"If you become friends or exist in an uneasy truce with weapons aimed at each other, it would unlock the fence for {emph}you."
It's possible that Mobius didn't feel like specifying teleportation only, and decided to use a misleading metaphor, but it's also possible that the developers had zero reason to let us manually walk out of Big Mt. Shall we also assume that it's impossible to walk up 45 degree hills, because they have the wrong texture? Or that using rope to climb out of a window is just impossible?
You're confusing what the player can't do, with what the characters can't do. You're also confusing 'we can't rule something out ' points with 'this is definitely what happened'. My only assumption is that Christine was lobotomized. If I didn't assume that, I would have to make other assumptions. I prefer to make the fewest assumptions. It's parsimonious.
You assume no developer oversights (false), that lobotomites have no electrodes in their skulls (unlikely), that it was a botched implant surgery (speculation), she was electroshocked (speculation), Ulysses interrupted it and detoured to put the recording in the cells (speculation and illogical), that Elijah believed her alive (false) and used trains to trap her (false), that Mobius would have her brain (speculation), etc. Really, I could go on.
Mostly I argue that there are gaps in what we know, and that certain things are possible. You're suggesting we can fill it based on what hasn't been said. That's not a logical argument. Especially not when we are explicitly told not to rule out 'unforeseen solutions to escaping Big Mt'. Which is basically the premise of the entire story. Oh no, wait, it is literally the premise of the entire story.
"But what if the characters just forgot I am right?"
But what if you can only argue against a strawman because I keep dismantling everything you say? It's also ironic that you keep forgetting that we're talking about characters that have forgotten almost everything, and then you act like that makes you right.
