nyibelunger said:
ad modding as criterion..
No of course it isn't only one criterion, but modding change you from "talker" to "doer". Instead of talking whats wrong i can do it better (not metioning that there will be much better mood).
ad statistics showing the percentage of modders among fans
almost every team is looking for new blood (some even died because lack of interest)...there is 14367 registered fans, lets assume that only 10% visit NMA regularly...Do you still need statistics to prove that majority of people just talk (what is wrong and they would do different)?
Face it, the world is like 99% 'talkers' with everything, there is no single gaming community were an actual large part of the people that play a game can/will/want to add any contribution in some constructive way. Democracy only works because there's such a hell of lot of people who just talk and even more who just shut up and listen. People who game, lots. People who game and talk on forums about it, some. People who game, talk and are in the modding stuff, depending on how easy it is to mod, pretty much always hardly any.
And just because people have gripes with a game doesn't mean they're all supposed to rise up in arms like an angry wave of patriots defending their pride, use all of their free time to learn coding, creating graphics and whatnot. It's a nice principle to 'do' instead of 'speak', but there's merit to talking as well. People often make quite valid points and even though there's this tiny, one-in-a-million chance that it'll actually have effect in the end, at least it was there.
And hell, the entire modding community might run out of ideas after a while if there wasn't this huge forest of people sprawling with ideas and speaking about them on forums like these. And then there are the people who actually keep a community and forum like this running. Without this there wouldn't even be an easy option to talk about the game. Heck, if you want to keep a forum up and running without it being clogged up by spam, idiots, trolls, fools, whatever, you've got a pretty much full time job on your hands. I've done it with smaller forums and there already it was a huge task of getting done well.
Though the old saying goes that speaking is silver and silence is gold, silver ain't worthless either. So just because entire forum communities aren't up in rage and learning code and art doesn't mean they aren't allowed to care.