Gunslinger-
I think you should not be too harsh with Gunslinger or Jeeva.
In Chapter 1, Gunslinger was really just an action character built on a construct that Fang had initiated. The factions of our story are, primarily, creatures of Fang's imagination, even if they are based on arch-types found in Fallout 1 and 2.
But I agree, that you were having trouble with him in Chapter 2. This was one of the reasons we discussed these issues during that chapter and I think why you were getting bored with him in Chapter 2. It's not that Caleb didn't have potential to grow as a person and a character, but rather that you hadn't taken the role on. I think perhaps because you were stuck with the Roland character in mind, that you had yet to create a character of your own.
So I think what you are doing with Caleb in this chapter is great. He needs to develop and to have depth. It is better to develop character and personality than just run through a series of gun fights and action sequences. Plot without character gets boring after awhile, simply because if you don't have characters who are real, you don't have characters you care about. SO then why do you care if they survive or not?
This is something we should all think about. A chain of adventures without developed characters is just boring. Think about some of your favorite films. Its not usually the cool action scenes we like, or the special effects, but the characters we are drawn to.
With regard to Jeeva, I think you shouldn't be too hard with Roguehex on that. Jeeva is growing as a person, but Rogue gave you quite a bit to work with. If you look at Chapter 2, Jeeva is in many ways the leader that Caleb is not. He rallies his men, has their best interests in mind, has their loyalty and trust, and is charismatic. He's brave and loyal and pro-active, not willing to be just a victim of circumstances. There is a code of honor, even among slavers, that he subscribes too. He's kind of cool. Chapter 2 is a tragedy for Jeeva, as his comrades and his men are virtually wiped out on some foolish mission not really of his own volition. That he has been "set up" is a good reason for motivating him throughout.
Much of the question about Jeeva has been about the morality of slaving in a post-apocalyptic world. We can say, based on our norms, that slaving is wrong (Although if you read this months National Geographic you would find that slaving is comparatively a more extensive phenomena now than ever). Regardless, Jeeva's response has been that slaving in a post-apocalyptic world is a better alternative than others (working as a mercenary or raider), that human life is not as valuable but at least he often saves humans who would otherwise be killed, provides a service valuable to others, and that, in many ways, he too is a creature of his circumstances. This is a character that has to live with a stigma and has managed to do just that. Regardless of whether you like what he does, he has redeeming values. So its a good pairing.
SO you have a lot to play with.
PM me, really the lyrics were that bad? the ghouls-mutant sex? Sorry but the story was dragging!