The Vault Dweller said:
The reason why I said it was made badly is that while it is excellent as an example of the C&C Tiberian series it is bad as an example of a proper RTS. The units are way unbalanced and it's possible to play balanced and turtle, but not rush. Ever.
Well, I consider the lack of rushing capability it's plus, as it's not a race "who manages to pump out more infantry in the first five minutes and rush" anymore.
By the way I've been meaning to say this to you in a PM for a long time now. I am impressed and gladdened that you are an editor for the C&C wiki. Not only since I love the games and you have great taste, but I in fact got alot of information off the site and I'm loving how you wrote it in the context of the games.
Why, thank you, I feel flattered, especially when it comes from the Best Dude Ever.
QFT. C&C is a cartoony game, in a campy style. Red Alert 2 turned the artwork of the series into an episode of Loony-Toons with guns. EA, instead of refining the glory and epic awesomness of Tiberium Sun and RA1, dumbed it down to the point that anyone with any amount of chromosomes could play it.
One thing with which I disagree always is that C&C is cartoony and campy. I find it disturbingly real, as real life
is campy. It hits me like a brick from a gravity gun in the Soviet intro in Red Alert, where Gradenko reports on the test of Sarin gas, in a scientific "look how interesting this is" tone, that "children took 15 seconds and adults took longer, 18 to 42 seconds".
I just can't feel the cartoon or camp when the game introduces some serious elements.
In RA2 this was shattered by the general aesthetic. The first Allied mission wasn't bad and the Soviet missions, thanks to Yuri were generally quite good and "almost-RA" but the FMVs and stupid elements like the GIs unable to hold up window covers or dropping a Canadian flag when the "hiding" US president transmits completely put me off.
The hilarity was most evident in Yuri's Revenge, and Carville reporting that our best operatives gave their lives to get the location of Yuri's cloning operations in Australia only prompted a smile, rather than any determination.