As a game? It was OK. Maybe even mediocre when taking into account balance. As an interactive movie? Masterful storytelling. It's like playing playing Arcanum and Planescape where the battles just get in the way of the experience. I hated DeWitt but still managed to get invested in the story. The final cutscene where Spoiler: ...... the music syncs up with the disappearing Elizabeths??? OUTSTANDING. @thread topic. Most overrated game? Fallout 3.