squeehunter said:
Things that seem to bother a lot of you don't bother me.
-The BOS as a whole haven't gone soft. Only the ones led by Lyons have. The "outcasts" mentioned in the developer diary seem to only be interested in technology still.
That's not the issue.
The issue that they're there in the first place. Sure it's not unreasonable to expect that there will be remnants of the U.S. Army on the East Coast- just like it's not unreasonable to expect there will be some in the Midwest, and ESPECIALLY in Alaska.
But- the issue is, it's the Brotherhood of Steel. They're supposed to be insular, very protective of their technology, and not too keen on splinter groups.
If anyone left the group, unless there was a massive firefight or something, they'd probably just be tossed out unceremoniously without any equipment.
Just having them on the East Coast is a massive ret-con. That's the issue, really.
-I'm sure there's a good reason why Jet is in the east coast. If there's not, it's not going to bother me.
Myron was the only one who knew how to make the stuff. Unless he's on the East Coast (woooo.... anyone else sense a ret-con here?) or someone managed to get his notes- which might not even exist, anyway- there's no reason to have Jet in the game. Could've had any other made-up drug and it would've been fine.
-If you can have a super powerful BB gun than what's so wrong with a gun that shoots teddybears?
First off, the BB Gun was an easter egg- and a sort of lame one, at that. And it was ridiculous, no doubt about that.
But the important point is this- unless a teddy bear is jammed full of heavy metal objects, or rocks, or something, there's no way it'll do any appreciable damage. At which point you'd just ask "Why use a teddy bear in the first place? Why not just use what's IN the bear?"
To say nothing of the fact that the force of the blast would rip it to tiny bits of fluff anyway.
-A car powered by micro-fusion cells shouldn't explode when shot but neither should a car full of gasoline but I can live with both in a game.
Soooo... because it's a staple of stupid action movies and video games, it's okay?
These are cars that have sat for over two hundred years. The idea that, even if the fuel cells are nuclear, that they'd still be radioactive, and even moreso, that they'd be combustible, is so beyond moronic it's not even funny.
FO3 should have just stuck with how the original Fallouts handled cars: as rusted-out useless hulks. Well, except for the Highwayman, but that was kinda silly anyway.
-What exactly is wrong with the Fat Man? I can't understand that. It was an experimental weapon that you got your hands on. It's basically just a Davey Crockett.
-Radiation
-The Davey Crockett wasn't a short-range (nay, point-blank range) weapon like the Fat Man, and this point's been discussed to beyond death.