It's that short? Okay, will do.
For someone who says he likes the game, he has an odd penchant for exaggerating every negative whenever it comes to
Demon's Souls. The game is NOT short at all. Not in the least bit.
Dark Souls is a much shorter game, with much less involved levels.
Demon's Souls will take you a good 10-20 hours to beat on your first try, assuming your skills are still sharp from solid experience from
Dark Souls. But the two games are not to be confused; they're 2 completely different beasts. Some (not all) of the levels in DeS will make you their bitch, and the bosses in general will laugh at the sorry excuse for "experience" that their successor counterparts have left in your laps.
If you take your time and enjoy the game, it will easily rack up no less than 40-50 hours for a single NG run. If you rush it, I think the world record for Platinum from start to finish is about 20 hours, and that includes TONS of glitch abusing which you're doubtless completely unaware of. So, take it from me, you're going to be in for a (great) ride, not a brief one. But by COMPARISON of an entire series, knocking out DeS will be the much shorter route. By comparison of THAT, stumbling into the maze-like mess that is MGS storytelling is an even larger endeavor. So sitting through about 50 hours of cutscenes and another several hundred hours of gameplay for the 10-odd games that make up that behemoth of a series, obviously that will take much longer.
I just warped through the first archstone (archestone?) and can already tell I'll enjoy the game, and also that it is only now that I realize these games really were made with a controller in mind.
Yes, like I've said many a time, you're not doing the games justice if you don't play them on a PS3. They were made FOR PS3s, not 360s, not PCs. The first game was dedicated to its atmosphere and world building, so if you like it already after just entering 1-1, you're gonna really love the game. Also, while WAY nastier than Blighttown,
Demon's Souls equivalent won't present you with framerate issues (not that Blighttown ever presented that to me, but people keep insisting it's common) while you traverse it.
The most fun I have with the game is deciding how I wish to traverse the levels when I first unlock them on a brand new character. Since you start out really weak, and every area has certain foes that you're totally unprepared to face without proper equipment, yet every area has "key" item pickups, it's always fun choosing a different route, so I'll have a completely different character by the 3rd level because of the route I chose compared to the last character, who went by a different route. Unlike
Dark Souls, in which you MAY be lucky enough to acquire very rare and special drops from particular enemies early on (the Black Knight Sword from the first Black Knight, the Trident from the first Channeler, etc), these aren't subject to drop rates. It's all up to planning. It's a ton of fun! =D