Why is it that when 'we' are coming up with an explaination "we're reading too much in it" but when someone else comes up with one to explain why Fallout 3 is/might be good then it's fine.
Bethsoft shouldn't be making these mistakes in the first place and requiring either side to guess at their reasoning.
The assumption that the Player is the one with the pip boy 3000 is a fairly easy one to make.... I haven't seen anyone else with one. Does that mean you're wrong & I'm right? Nope, but it does mean both of us are guessing based on our knowledge.
What are your thoughts on the Pip boy 3000 possibly being general equipment that any NPC or mob can have? Personally I feel it's a mistake as it means that upgrades for the Pip boy will be more common and as result lessen the feeling the world is falling apart.