DemonNick said:
A lot of people on NMA complain about stuff like the Fat Man being goofy and stupid and over the top, but I distinctly remember FO1 and FO2 being hyped up on the basis of their gory death animations, the grotesqueness of the mutants, etc, etc, in magazine previews and ads in comic books.
Oh Folco, how do you let yourself get baited...
Sorry, dude, just can't help myself... must answer...
OK, so from someone who ranks F1 as one of his all-time favorite games, is an old games curmudgeon (I had a 2600 back when those were
new after all), but is NOT an NMA regular, I'll take a stab at this answer. I wish I could just recycle a post I know I made during the OMG PREVIEW SPOILERS period before F3 came out, but apparently bethsoft boards don't go that far back. Oh well.
You may think this is a nitpick and does not go directly to the point you were making, but it actually (IMHO) does. Those of us who were hating on the Fat Man when it was revealed didn't really care about it being an over the top BFG9000 gun (OK maybe a little, but not the main reason). This issue was (and is) that the Fat Man goes completely against the themes and atmosphere of Fallout.
In the original games, nukes were feared and respected. You only set them off as plot devices. Those things just blasted the damn planet to hell, after all. F3 on the other hand has a little too much
How I Learned to Love the Bomb and not enough
Failsafe for my tastes. That's why I think people objected to the Fat Man. Not that it caused gory over the top death animations.
Oh, and for the record, the gory death animations (unless you took bloody mess) were a lot less frequent in F1 than F3.