I don't think people on here are old school "fanboys" I notice a lot of gamers using this term now a days, but use it in very general terms simply because someone "likes" something which really isn't what a fanboy is.
Of course not. Even the old games have their flaws.
Many people posting here, simply like quality in role playing.
I guess it is easy to believe, "Ehey! They just hate evertyhing new at NMA!". But a lot of people here actually enjoy Borderlands and shooters. But if someone's seriously thinking that Fallout 3 and 4 are deep role playing games and simply hates on Planescape and Fallout because they are not "cinematic" enough, than well, what else is there to say?