Maphusio said:
Sri Lanka just donated 25,000 USD for this... Wow thats... thats well lets just say we better be nice and invade them next to "straiten" out things there.
About 30,000 Sri Lankans died during the Tsunami disaster and the US was the first to react, so despite their own problems, they're bound to help
Murdoch said:
And yes, I know he cut his vacation off and flew over the scene (at 30,000 feet probably, lot of good that does) to respond, but where the fuck is the first response?! FEMA?!
Cutting off his holiday once the disaster started is irrelevant. He was not working during the days leading up to it, days when everyone knew it was going to be bad. He was still relaxing. Ey.
Layle said:
Side note: they should have never developed the city of new orleans as it stands, it was "asking" to be a lake.
Should've could've didn't. Half of Holland including most of its population AFAIK is under sea level too.
welsh said:
Weren't you the one arguing against Europe's integration policy and pro that of the US, where people are kind and everyone gets equal oppertunity? How does this fit in there? Or was that just about muslems?
Brady said:
Of course, but the writer is drawing racial angst concerning Rodney King and tieing that in with the chaos following a Natural Disaster in New Orleans. As if it was a Black thing.
True, this is false, but it is interesting to see that two situations which are seperate of each other make an interesting combination here; most victims of such natural disasters are poor. Most poor people in NO are black. Point one is the result of social inequality, which is something we've all learned to accept, so what is point two? Racism? Just the way it is?
And when point 1 and 2 combine, what you effectively get is the slaughter of the darkies. By natural causes, 'course
Brady said:
I also don't think it's fair to compare evacuation efforts with Cuba. A nation much smaller than the United States, where almost all aspects of one's life are controlled by the state. Most of the people killed by this hurricane are idiots that refused to leave their homes.
Cuba evacuated 1.5 million people and their goods with apparent ease. Explain to me how Cuba being a small country matters, then.
And no, most people killed by this hurricane were people with nowhere else to go, too poor to move anywhere else even temporarily. How did you suppose homeless people were supposed to escape? Or those too poor to afford a simple bus ticket, let alone real transport?
No, Cuba is a good measuring rod. Yes, the situation is different, but Cuba shows the result of a lack of short-term political thinking. It *knows* a hurricane will hit it, so it spends time and effort in planning and investing ahead for this. Years, decades go into this. It's like Holland since the
North Sea Flood of 1953, that flood resulted in us designing and building what still stands as one of the most ingenious systems of levies ever made and all cities in the Netherlands still have detailed, well-planned and well-invested disaster plans, not just for floods either even if that's the only thing left to fear
Brady said:
What exactly is it that Bush is supposed to do anyways? He's most definitely at fault concerning budget allocation, but in crisis, the President is mostly a figurehead, and lacks much practical pull coordinating the actions of State and even Federal agencies. Though, he had organized a task force to help provide relief in the sea the day after the storm, how much reassuring can he do for people that have no electricity?
He *might just have* cut his vacation short about 3 days in advance and spent some time planning and co-ordinating post-disaster relief. But that might just be me and my odd conception that the head of a country should do something about disasters, while you seem to think he can stand idly by.
And he might've possible said to Canada, the Netherlands and other neighbours offering help "yes, please, we're in trouble, send whatever you can spare", so that the Dutch warship, full of personel trained in disaster relief, could've left from the Netherlands Antilles earlier or so that the Canadians could've actually sent in their ships too.
welsh said:
Except that Cuba is tremendously poor
Tremedously poor? No it isn't. It's in the high-standard portion of the HDI list of the UNDRP, number 52, above Mexico and Belarus, above Russia and Brazil.
Briosafreak said:
but mainly with the raising of funds (on wich they still beat the Europeans, to be fair)
What? Not true. Though they beat the Portuguese, to be sure...
A quick calculation puts EU foreign aid, not counting all memberstates but just those in the top-33 donors, at roughly 4650 million USD, compared to the 1981 million USD from the US.
The private donation of the US (1031 million USD) amount to 0.09% of the GNP. Other percentages for private donations: up to .41% for the Netherlands, .92% for Ireland, .22% for Germany, .15% for Finland, .10% for Austria. I do not see how the US has got the EU "beat"
What the US did for the Tsunami was not raise funds for long-term reactions. That's what the EU did. The US was instrumental in a quick military reaction for first-minute aid.
Bradylama said:
I didn't say that they could, but if this is because I said most of the people who are dead stayed at their homes, that's exactly the case. I said they "refused to leave their homes." If somebody that can't leave their home "refuses to leave" then it's mostly an empty gesture. Most of the people that will be found dead are entire families that drowned in their houses as the flood waters rose.
Most of those people found drowned in their own houses were desperate people, unable to leave and who, as human instinct dictates, felt that home was the safest place to remain. The house was solid, they'd have at least some supplies.
I don't know why you feel so honour-bound to protect the Prez in this, but you should watch out for treading on the ridiculous, which includes blaming the deaths on the dead.
Bradylama said:
Of the military. The president should never achieve the kind of clout that would allow him direct influence in disaster relief.
Disaster relief is probably one of the only situations that exist were democracy really needs to shove over in favour of immediate aid. Let him declare a state of emergency and march in the fucking troops, why not?