RangerBoo
Resident Schizo Poster
I don't really see why the Legion has to be morally grey. There is nothing wrong with being able to choose an 'evil' side. And Obsidian executes on it well, because there are real reasons for them to be the way they are (other than "post-apocalypse, therefore crazy cannibals"). I think it is less interesting if every faction is equivalent in terms of desirability.
And while in subsequent lore, it might be possible to show something good having come out of the Legion, I think that painting Legion rule as stable in a positive way would be unfaithful to history. The Legion is a textbook dictatorial, even fascist regime. As Sawyer mentions, it relies on Caesar to hold together, and also relies on constant expansion, both as a source of slave labor, and to justify its militant nature. It is strong, but not at all stable, just like the regimes throughout history that inspired it.
I still think it's a desirable option because it is interesting for these reasons. The Legion is villainous, but they're not straw man villains, IMO. And there is already so much moral ambiguity in the game, that it's nice to see some variety in the topography.
My thoughts exactly. What the Legion does is terrible but what they are doing is no different then what civilizations, even those that give birth to the western world, have done in the past to insurance peace, prosperity and growth. I wouldn't mind seeing some good that the Legion has done or good that has popped up from their conquest in the southwest just to make me question myself. A good villain should after all make you question yourself, your beliefs and motives. The Legion have a "ends justice the means" and "necessary evil for the greater good" type mentality. However dialogue in game leads me to believe that things won't turn out well for the Legion in the long run when Caesar dies. Kinda reminds of how things weren't really too peachy in Rome after the deaths of Julius Caesar and Augustus. I hate their guts but at the same time I find them fascinating and wanting to learn more about them.