Fallout: New Vegas
Going into the game what are you looking forward to?
Making different choices faction-wise. I never comitted to a complete Caesar's Legion playthrough.
After having completed it what did you think of the game?
I think it's a nice game when modded, but some aspects still leave a lot to be desired. Enemies feel bullet spongy, and installing a mod to address this negates Skills, and what's worse, the whole DT/DR aspect (as you can easily tackle a Giant Radscorpion, an otherwise tanky enemy).
I feel there are too many locations which are not memorable at all. Caves, offices, and the like which feel copypasted. The Goodsprings Cave with the coyotes is nice in that it offers a sizeable amount of loot the player won't find anywhere else that early in the game. But later on, similar caves aren't nearly as rewarding.
There's a lot of emptyness in the map which shows in the game's lack of a hub-based world map. This is a problem that neither Fallout or Fallout 2 had, and what's more, those games featured random encounters so that no two travels from A to B were identical.
There's the repetitive voice-acting due to lack of diversity in the voice actors (with one actor voicing many, many NPCs). Unsurprisingly the most memorable NPCs are the ones who don't share voice actors with other characters.
The Strip is totally disappointing. I wonder how I felt about this on my first playthrough.
What would you improve?
I would either turn it into an isometric cRPG, or take a Deus Ex approach, going for a level-based experience, with a mix of hub world. That is, you can travel between levels, but each level is meant to provide its own gameplay experience (as opposed to serving only as a place for interacting with NPCs, with no gameplay value otherwise).
What's your thoughts on the main quest?
I didn't like it. My issue is that there's no "plot twist" or something new to look up to. From the very beginning you are told that there are factions warring for the Mojave, so the player can pretty much expect to side with one of them. The closest thing is the Yes Man reveal, but unfortunately most faction quests are mirrors of each other. Only the NCR features many, many independent quests, and you can do them without even being an NCR member (e.g. hunting down the Fiends).
If old, does the game still hold up in 2022?
While not old, I don't think it held up gameplay-wise even in 2010. Not even Fallout 3 held up in 2008.
If not Fallout 1, does it add to Fallout lore in a good way?
I definitely like the lore of New Vegas. Apart from my gameplay issues (of which I consider the lack of quests for other factions a gameplay issue as opposed to a writing issue), I think the game's writing is great and every change it made was for the best. Caesar's Legion, the expansion of the NCR, MOTHERFUCKING RANGER COMBAT ARMOR, how it dealt with the Remnants and Super Mutants, etc. It's all great. I just wish it was a better game.
What's the game's strengths and weaknesses?
Its strength is the worldbuilding. Its weaknesses are... everything else.
What would you like to change in the game?
I think Cass and Lily are placed in inconvenient locations. Lily is likely to be the last companion you will meet, and Cass requires some backtracking to get her. A far cry from the way you meet ED-E, Boone, Veronica, Arcade, and Rex. At least Raul is in Black Mountain.
What build did you use during your play-through?
Guns, Survival, and Barter. I just love guns. Energy weapons lack the punch they had in classic Fallout.
What's your weapon of choice?
The Hunting Shotgun is a favorite of mine. The Trail Carbine is fantastic as well.
Describe your favourite quest and why you like it!
I really enjoy Vault 34 as a dungeon. It has scripted sequences which the game sorely lacks. So Hard Luck Blues it is.
What's your favourite location in the game?
Vault 34, for the reasons mentioned.
What ending did you strive for/get?
My first Caesar's Legion run. Saved Caesar as well. Talking with Lanius like comrades in arms was fantastic.
If the game is on Steam then write a sentence that would catch the NMA perception of it and that we could use for our Steam curator.
"Though mechanically unfulfilling as a roleplaying game and overly ambitious at times, Fallout: New Vegas is the payoff to the worldbuilding gamble set up in Fallout 2."
Is Fallout: New Vegas a good sequel to the previous games?
It's the best sequel we could hope to get after Bethesda's acquisition of the IP.
Do you consider Fallout: New Vegas to be canon?
Yes.