Surf Solar said:
I see where you coming from, but considering how many people (often innocent?) the PC kills during the game, does it really matter that much that a few more get killed in a nuclear explosion? Not even speaking of that you can kill way more people with the Fatman and it's "awesome mini nukes".
It is a matter of context, killing to survive or fighting in a war or even revenge is one thing, but wiping out a whole city for slight material gain, with no back story, just a few hours into the game, using the same method used wipe almost every living person on earth is a little extreme, especially given how the game attempts to frame it as fairly reasonable choice and the consequences are so minor; after taking such an action, pretty much every somewhat civilized human in the game should want you dead, but somehow even the Brotherhood wants you help them instead of killing you on sight, and Moira who somehow survived through fairy magic, still wants your help writing a book, because it wouldn't be fair to make another quest unfinishable, after your decision to mass murderer.
The Fatman is retarded too (so are around about 1000 other things in the game, the things we learned from Fallout 3 thread is amazing, and it is probably just scratching the surface).