Funny, some of your reactions remind me of the Bethesda fans vs original Fallout fans interaction
Bullshit. This is better than I remember!
Call it what you want, I have been playing FPS games for quite some time, probably longer than you did, and even at the time the Halo SP campaign was average in general.
The general problem was the repetitiveness of levels and of course the damn re use of a particular one.
Even gamers at the time mentioned that in posts and reviews.
And FPS games at the time were already capable of more.
Show it to people now and they wonder what honestly the hype was about.
Ok, remember that Fallout:Anniversary example? Try this:It now has every weapon from Fallout 2,3 and new Vegas.Oh and Hardcore mode! That would be just great?!? No it would not would it?
Wrong example as a Fallout remake would not work like this.
A better example would be Half Life vs Half Life Source, and HL Source does improve in many ways.
Also this is baiting.
See the above example. Now,as for it costing too much, well, marketing people saw a good opertunity to earn more money,plain and simple.
And as the poster above me mentioned, they could as well have released the original in some new box with extra maps and call it Anniversary addition as the budget in general was rather wasted.
I think you should take off the nostalgia glasses and have a good look CEA and the other games in the series (outside Wars of course), especially in what they added to make for a better and more enjoyable gameplay.
Halo CE has always been a bit of a basic shooter and it stands out even more today.
As
Walknut wrote, the new mechanics and gear would have made this a more interesting experience.