I was counting Luke's and Charlie's shots earlier, not their kills. I went back through the story and counted everyone's kills today, though (not counting the ones at the bottom of page 13, since Luke was over his limit for the number of shots):
Alice-1
Azadeh-27
Charlie-14
Luke-22
Azadeh wins! Okay, there's no actual prize, but she does get bragging rights. But there's plenty more zombies where those came from. The above kills total 64. Since there were 180 walkers to start with, that leaves 116 remaining.
It's true that the dogs' skills make them very useful in detecting zombies so they can alert the humans and they might be able to distract them by barking loudly, but in terms of actually killing zombies that's best left to the humans. Guns do more damage, they do it from a distance, and they can hit a zombie in the head (which would be difficult for a dog). Plus we don't know what would happen to a dog that bites a zombie.
It's a pity about Alex and Felice. Mr. Foo realized that Alex was a potential teacher when he made his Psych roll way back at the beginning, but Alex went off jogging before anyone at the motel realized anything was going on. At least Michael survived to tell the tale, though.
Flip would be quite deadly with grenades and Molotov cocktails. Those other skinheads have a bunch of grenades, so maybe he can get them to give him some.
Mr. Foo is decent in a fight except for his extreme slowness. Still, when attacking an enemy that's unaware of him or a zombie from an unassailable defensive position he can do a lot of damage. He's extremely deadly with a pistol, but he needed to give it to Stephanie so they can both shoot zombies at the same time with a reasonable chance to hit. If he used the pistol, then Stephanie would be left with the MP-5.
Stephanie with an MP-5?
Yeah, that would be cool...if only she had the skill. But with only the base 15% (which could be raised to a whopping 30 by firing bursts, but at quite a high cost of ammo), it's much more efficient for her to use the pistol and Mr. Foo the SMG. Her skill there could be higher, but it's not bad, and the pistol is excellent:
As for Brownson, the only real choice is whether Joe or Baldwin uses the second shotgun. If it were up to me I'd go with Baldwin. His shotgun skill may be a bit lower, but Joe is stronger and can move the barrel faster. Once that's done, more people can shoot. With Kimberly using the first shotgun and Erica busy setting up the pump, three of the remaining four are needed to move the fuel and two of them can't use a shotgun. Still, it's up to Stompie and Gonzalez to decide, but decide fast!