I am not completely anti military. I see the need for it. But the question, do we need MORE?
Europe should be able to hold its own. We can't at this point.
If the US decides to become isolationist and non-interventionalist, we could be screwed.
Is it fair to overly rely on the US for our own protection?
The US didn't mind way back when because of the Soviet threat. But that's gone now. Those simple days are over. We live in a far more complex world.
If we want to be taken seriously (also in terms of foreign policy), we need to stand on our own two legs, instead of relying on our burly kid brother.
This would be, in this day and age, suicide anyway when you consider how many of the global players own nuclear weapons in all kind of forms, with the NATO and all the other military structures.
Except you don't have any nukes.
The Brits do. The French do. The Americans do.
You don't.
NATO might not be around forever. Or the most important members might withdraw due to a change in foreign policy. It's happened in the past. The French did not want to play ball and dropped out.
EUFOR already exists. Nordic Battle Group already exists. Intercountry cooperation already exists on many levels.
Nuclear weapons are a game changer in that respect. Doesn't mean there will never be conflicts. But I think those will be a lot more like what we see in Ukraine or the middle east, africa etc.
All examples of conflicts which need a functional conventional army with a sound logistics train and a strategic airlift capacity.
Those aren't things you solve with air superiority bombing, UAVs and proxy armies.
When it comes to military and the military industry, my opinion is, trim the fat not the muscle.
Ironically, we've largely been trimming the muscle, not the fat.
We've been grossly underspending on personnel, training & logistics. Sure, we're spending money on new helicopters, new planes, new APCs, etc. But we barely train with them. We don't have strategical airlift capability to transport them. We have a military which is quickly ageing (top heavy, full of old farts).
Most EU armies get stretched thin when participating in peacekeeping and mentoring. This means that in case of war, they don't stand a friggin' chance.
There are some exceptions to the rule (France for instance), but what I'm saying above largely holds true across the EU.