All of the reviews basically boil down to it's buggy, janky, rather ugly at times, stutters, too heavily focused on combat, isn't very compelling, the ai sucks, and the story sucks - but it's fun because there is lots of stuff to do. Most mainstream reviewers have praised Bethesda for the direction the series has gone, even going as far to compare it to Borderlands - one reviewer noting that more features from that series might show up in the future. No mention hardly of consequences in most of the reviews. Some reviews praised the lack of reading. Other are full blown in love with the fact that the game doesn't end after the letdown of an ending(s). Most are content with the main story being trash.
Almost every single new feature in the game has been criticized for various reasons. Still it gets positive reviews aside from those who see through the bullshit. Nearly all complaints have been excused as typical Bethesda issues and mods will save the game. No criticism can be brought upon this game. It gets dismissed before a logical discussion can be had. The streamlining has gained them one of the most loyal fanbases imaginable and they know it. The comments section on most gaming sites right now might be one of the most infuriating things about the whole mess. It's the same fucking thing that happens every single time one of their games comes out. What a joke.