Fallout 3 lives!
Many people here argue that Bethesda "just could've copied the design from Fallout 1+2!". Yeah, and I bet they could've reused the graphics engine too, and maybe the plotline, and...
Bethesda bought the Fallout 3 license so they could create a new game, their own NEW version of a classic franchise. How unsatisfying wouldn't it be for them just to reuse all of the mechanics and looks from the two previous games? I know it would be unsatisfying for me.
The intro/tutorial sounds fun to me, and I believe it will give a good sense as to what is it like living in a vault, and the contrast when exloring the outside world will then be even greater.
As for the view perspective: Great. Don't know quite yet if I'll play it in 1st or 3rd person view, but it's the way I wanted to explore the wasteland - I've already seen it in isometric view, and look forward to seing it closer and more intimately.
The VATS seem like a rational solution to the anti-FPS problem, as you really couldn't have both FPP and TB.
The new Pip-Boy exceeds my expectations: I applaud Bethesda for having the guts to reinvent the Pip-Boy the way they did, and while many conservative fans may whine about it, the more openminded of us can appreciate it's visual flair.
I'm not really exited about the supermutant, but wouldn't want all of them to look like Marcus either, so I welcome some change (and no, it's really not an orc at all).
I like the Fatman alot, and by calling it cheesy and too cliche or too obvious, your kinda taking away Bethesdas rights to create something new in the FO universe; if The Fatman had been in Fallout 1, you would all be praying the the iconic weapon returned this time around. Nostalgia has a tendency to glorify things a bit more than they deserve (and if Fallout 1 was made today by the original developers, it most certainly wouldn't be like the Fallout 1 we know...)
Yes, call me a troll or untrue Fallout fan, but don't flame me for having an open mind and not wanting a new version of either Fallout 1 or Fallout 2, but a new game altogether, worthy of the Fallout 3-label. If new ideas aren't welcome, I don't see how Bethesda can create anything but Fallout 2,5.