Can't go wrong with a S&W 686... That said, I feel the sweet spot for a revolver lies around 5", not 6". For extended shooting sessions anyway.
DammitBoy said:
Novices should always be trained in basic firearm safety with a small caliber like the .22 to avoid ruining their ability to fire without flinching. How you start out is very important. Technique is much more important to proper gun handling than showing off your guns.
Starting with a .357 magnum with hotloads is just plain stupid. I see morons do this to women at a range all the time. They think it's funny to watch the reaction to the recoil, the loud report and the muzzleblast.
Actually, no. Not at all.
I always fell into the same trap as you. I always had novices shoot the .22LR first, then move up to 9x19mm and then maybe something tough like .357Mag or even .44Mag for kicks when I thought they were ready.
But no more. I will still use this tactic when I know someone is still on the fence about shooting or even against shooting (we try to convert antis here).
But if they've expressed serious interest in shooting and have shown that they are enthousiastic about it, I start them off with .357Mag (usually 5 rounds, hot by american standards). I then move over to 9x19mm, which suddenly seems easy as pie and they love it. And then .22LR which is just plinking all out. (moving back & forth as they feel like it, let them choose)
Why have I switched the routine around? Well, my 'mentor' suggested it. He's a qualified initiator, examinator and IPSC trainer. He's shared his hobby with countless of novices, so I took his word for it and gave it a try. And he was right. Turns out that ESPECIALLY the women appreciate the starting off with the hot .357Mag (after proper explanation and perhaps use of snapcaps first if necessary).
You're mistaking my "hot .357Mag" for some asshat who pushes a weapon into a woman's hands and lets her shoot without even explaining to her how to hold the damn thing.
DammitBoy said:
It's kinda hard to untrain a flinch because somebody was an unthinking cocktard with a novice.
Regardless of starting with .22LR in the shooting session, people will flinch. You can try to prepare them for it, but they will to some extent. How much depends as much on the preparation and the person as it does on the calibre used to start the session.
Quite frankly, I've seen more people flinch when starting off with .22LR (they start flinching at 9x19mm and higher), whereas when you start bigger, the flinching virtually disappears as you progress. But again, this is more due to preparation and the person itself than due to the calibre shot.
DammitBoy said:
Safety glasses and hearing protection should always be provided and required when showing a noob around a firearm.
They are always required... Not only when dealing with noobs.
I've got light damage to my right eye while wearing glasses (and a cap & earpro). Case extracted with still some burning propellant in it, got flung out, bounced off the cap and behind my glasses (they were normal glasses not close fitting wrap-arounds).
Very unlucky, but just goes to show: always take precautions and even then it's never totally safe.
Now, I don't have a problem with the damage to the eye. It's just a slightly blurry spot that comes into view when my eyes get tired (i suspect it's the outer protective membrane that's damaged and when my eyes get tired the membrane is not pulled as tight as it should be, causing the slightly damaged spot to drift into view).