Joelzania
Look, Ma! Two Heads!
Tim Burton really feels like a stagnant director. All this trademark cartoon horror stuff is nice, but it's been done by the man better in the past.
I'm pretty sure they've been having the popstar of the day do the theme since the 70s. Only change over the years is what's considered popSub-Human said:Adele is the only good artist out there, I guess.
Sub-Human said:Adele is the only good artist out there, I guess.
Hmm...I disagree. He's done good stuff and bad stuff throughout his career. The Planet of the Apes remake was bad, but Frankenweenie isn't bad. It's a remake of his first successful short film, so it ought to embody his style.Joelzania said:Tim Burton really feels like a stagnant director. All this trademark cartoon horror stuff is nice, but it's been done by the man better in the past.
UniversalWolf said:It's a remake of his first successful short film, so it ought to embody his style.
The original short? Tell us what you think. I've never seen it.Joelzania said:UniversalWolf said:It's a remake of his first successful short film, so it ought to embody his style.
I didn't know that. I'm going to check that out now.
Well, Sergio Leone and Martin Scorsese and John Hughes and John Ford and lots of others did "the same thing" over and over, and it worked out okay. Personally I don't think Nightmare Before Christmas is the same thing as Edward Scissorhands is the same thing as Sleepy Hollow, but they're stylistically similar.SnapSlav said:It's just well known that Tim Burton HAS been doing the same thing over and over again for the majority of his film career, and that it's no secret.
UniversalWolf said:Well, Sergio Leone and Martin Scorsese and John Hughes and John Ford and lots of others did "the same thing" over and over, and it worked out okay. Personally I don't think Nightmare Before Christmas is the same thing as Edward Scissorhands is the same thing as Sleepy Hollow, but they're stylistically similar.SnapSlav said:It's just well known that Tim Burton HAS been doing the same thing over and over again for the majority of his film career, and that it's no secret.
At least Burton's not doing Avatar, Avatar 2, Avatar 3, and Avatar 4.
How about "Nightmare on the Planet of the Apes"? Oh wait, he already made that. Nevermind. Sleepy Hollow was awesome, though. I'm ashamed to say I haven't seen more of his flicks.TorontRayne said:Maybe he should start making a crapload of sequels and "re-imaginings".
It made a lot of money.Sub-Human said:Since then, I've always wondered what it had done to deserve so many Oscars.
UniversalWolf said:Those films are really "meh," in my opinion. There are some good moments, but they're matched blow for blow by utterly insipid moments, like Bilbo yelling "Gandalf!" in slow motion at the Moria bridge.
I remember the official position of the Tolkien estate being that (to paraphrase) the LotR novels were uniquely unsuitable for being made into movies, and I agree with that. Tolkien was a linguist, after all, and those books are so heavily dependent on language and the written word...it all gets lost in a screenplay. How much of the poetry and music in the books made it into the movies? Zero. Not to mention, there's just too much damn material to cram into three movies. Two movies per book might have had a chance.Sub-Human said:UniversalWolf said:Those films are really "meh," in my opinion. There are some good moments, but they're matched blow for blow by utterly insipid moments, like Bilbo yelling "Gandalf!" in slow motion at the Moria bridge.
Not just stupid moments. Very boring, too. All the characters are shallow and not memorable. The dialogue? Dull. There's just too many people introduced that Peter didn't have the time to properly develop any of them beyond the basic 'Angry guy, Kind guy' personality.