Brother None said:
shihonage said:
This point was made originally
here, I merely reiterated it. He puts it much better than I could.
I know, but the point is void as long as you call it Christmas, rather than say X-Mas (or my preferred converted holiday, SexMass).
I guess you forgot about the mass part (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_(liturgy)), but that only strengthen your argument.
So it should really be Christ-Mass.
But this is from The Oxford English Dictionary, to show the development of the expression (bold words by me):
1. a. The festival of the nativity of Christ, kept on the 25th of December. Usually extended more or less vaguely to the season immediately preceding and following this day, commonly observed as a time of festivity and rejoicing.
a1123 OE. Chron. an. 1101 Her on {th}isum {asg}eare to X{ptilde}es. mæssan heold se cyng Heanri{asg} his hired on Westmynstre. a1134 Ibid. an. 1127 {Edh}is {asg}ear heald se kyng Heanri his hird æt
Cristes mæsse on Windlesoure. 1340 Ayenb. 213 Ine zuyche festes ase at
cristesmesse. c1340 Gaw. & Gr. Knt. 471 Wel by-commes such craft vpon
cristmasse. c1489 CAXTON Sonnes of Aymon iii. 83 At
crystmasse and at ester, men ought to go vysit and see his good frende. 1489 Plumpton Corr. (1839) Introd. 114 The King..beganne Crysmas at Westmynster. 1495 Act 2 Hen. VII, c. 2 §5 Noon apprentice..[shall] pley..at the Tenys..in no wise out of Cristmas. 1568 GRAFTON Chron. II. 54 He went to Windsore, where he..kept his Christmas. 1605 CAMDEN Rem. Proverbs,
Christmasse cometh but once a yeare. 1635 SWAN Spec. M. (1670) 124 They also say, that a hot Christmas makes a fat churchyard. 1712 STEELE Spect. No. 509 {page}3 The Beadles and Officers have the Impudence at Christmas to ask for their Box. 1748 H. WALPOLE Lett., H. Mann 26 Dec., Here am I come down to what you call Keep my Christmas. 1820 W. IRVING Sketch Bk. 189 (Hoppe) Revelry was permitted..through the twelve days of Christmas.