I like Obsidian. That opinion is inflated somewhat because other companies making similar games have set the bar quite low. So, while I don't absolutely love their work, they are consistently above average and good at crafting RPG narratives in a game environment. And, in recent years the company has become better at shipping mostly-finished product that is less crashy, possibly just because the game engines they're working on are more mature.
I feel like Obsidian's writing has become safer and maybe a bit predictable, so as I become less disappointed with the actual resulting product, I am simultaneously less excited about upcoming releases. But that doesn't really mean they can't turn out a good game if they decided to. Surely you can't judge anything by the PR.