I've to pay tribute to you guys here. You're truly fighting since 10 years for a true Fallout 3. You really don't deserve such a farce like this.
But it's a sad trend, to change great old concepts, or let's better say, to make 'shiny graphics'...
There was a time, when gameplay and story was the main goal behind a game, but today it seems to be about shader (points toward his sig)...
While you brought up a 'discussion' or a comparison to adventure games, let me say one thing about that:
Monkey Island was a great series, until some dumphead came up with the idea to do it in 3D and a keyboard control... (I wonder why i enjoyed Grim Fandango and hated MI4)...
But back to the article, or much the discussion...
There are 2 core elements of computer games (for me, and they are set in this order!):
1. gameplay
2. stroy
The gameplay is the main element of game, who's saying "But the setting is the same" - sure, but why do you think games got classified by their genre and not by their story (Or graphics *coughs coughs*)?
Civilization is Civilization because of it's gameplay, it nearly has no story. But saying some real-time Civ-"Clone" (i never played this game and so i don't remind it's name) is civilization is utterly B***s**t. They both might have as main part 'conquering the world' or 'ruling' the world. But the gameplay makes a big difference.
Also the new Indiana Jones, this cheap Lara Croft-Clone, isn't a sequel to the true old Lucas Film Games Indiana Jones Adventures for me...
Keep in mind, that if you say 'Gameplay dosen't matter, as long as the they keep true to the setting and the story' the companys could come to the conclusion that they also could make games where you're only 'gameplay' is to click on the button reading 'next' to switching to the next video-scene....
Another comparison comes to mind:
Star Wars... i mean you got thousand of different (okay i'm overdoing it) genres of Star Wars games. But it's totaly unnatrual to say 'Knights of the old Republic' is a sequel to 'Jedi Academy' or 'X-Wing vs. Tie-Fighter' while the setting is mainly the same and they also keep true to the story....
So please stop trying to defend this 'Fallout 3' (it's not Fallout, but some other thing) with the word 'But the setting is like the old fallout.
I doubt their system will work out good, and after Oblivion (and a lot of other games where game companys made false promises about cool 'features', like multiple paths and so on, i won't believe any game magazine nor promises von Bethesda).
The graphics? Damn i don't care if the supermutant looking like an orc. Or a bit off Power-Armor, as long as they resemble a cewrtain similarity to the old ones. But seeing a more cold colour plaette and a more 'Realistic' design approach is too much...
So please take this from a guy, who never before posted here, nor in the Beth-fallout forums:
"It's not Fallout, even if it might become the greatest game ever in existance'".
Call it "Fallout - The later years" or something like this, but please please, don't pretend it to be the third installation of the original Fallout, because it isn't.
And while a lot of people here only want a true Fallout 3, stop complaining about them, when they complain about not getting it. Because they dont' get the game they want...
And saying "Nah you won't get the game you want, you've to take this as a replacement and you have to like it" is childish bu**s**t
So i hope my post did make sense up until now (or in other words, i hope my english was well enough to be understandable)...
So now to 'Random' 'trolling' (maybe in the wrong forum *G*):
I would suggest calling Beths Fallout:
'TYD - Fallout' (The Younger Discs - Fallout) , or something like that
The conversation system in Fallout and Oblivion the same? I guess chatting with a woman is also the same as having some more personal contact eh for you Xython...
And yeah, you could change the old Morrowind wiki style. But that would be under my 'false promises until i saw it done' things
Modding this Over-the-shoulder cam thing into a 'true' Fallout with the Beth-Tools? You ever tried anything with the Oblivion tools? - Heck, you can't even get what the player hit with from their scripting-language! (As far as i remember)...
And so you had either to find some wacky work-arounds for such things, or you had to hack a few original files, wich isn't actually allowed i think...
So the normal Oblivion tool was more a 'Give the sword higher damage'-thing as an 'Let's change the fundamental gameplay' thing.
Okay that's it for now.
I've just lef to excuse me for my english and for allways using 'you' instead of the names of you guys or more suitable terms...
Good Night/Morning/Midday...