Sander said:
Let me reiterate this for the thousandth time: it's not about whether or not people will *enjoy* this game, it's about whether this game will be a worthy successor. Nowhere in this entire thread have I or has anyone else presumed to tell people what they could enjoy, and the fact that you think we have only shows that you have not understood anything and are only blabbering your own little line again and again.
I think the reason for this confusion is that you continue to restate what you think is "worthy" in response to what I say that I would "enjoy". If you are not attempting to attack my statement of what I would enjoy, by swearing at me and telling me that I'm missing the point when I say it, what exactly is it that you are doing?
What I am saying is precisely about whether I will enjoy the game, I can tell you this very, very clearly. As I pressed the keys in the first post, and each post since, what I have been talking about is exactly that. If you choose to divert the point in my post, by responding and telling me what you think makes a "worthy" Fallout game, this is not a failing on my part, as all I have presumed to share is my opinion on what I'd enjoy.
If you want to make this a conversation about worthy Fallout titles, that's fine, but you should pick someone to target who is actually objecting to your objective definition, which is not what I'm doing. I'm simply saying that you can keep it, I have my own views I am not interested in adopting yours, but thankyou for sharing all the same.
Sander said:
For the final fucking time: a Fallout FPS game will not be a worthy successor. Not because it wouldn't be enjoyable, but because it would simply be a different kind of game.
I do not share your ability to declare my statements final, but nor would I want to. Instead I will respond to this gem in very simple form:
* I am not interested in debating what you think would be a "worthy" Fallout game. Nor am I interested particularly in laying down the law as to what a "worthy" Fallout game is. Similarly, my lack of interest in this topic is not affected when you point out that you are not sharing an opinion, but an "objective definition of Fallout" which was passed down from God himself.
* I am interested in saying what I liked about the original Fallout games, and what it is that I would like to see come back in the new one. I have made this intention exceptionally clear, and I don't feel that I have been hostile towards anyone in doing this. For this reason, I am still confused by the fact that you appear to be attacking my statement of what i would enjoy, over and over, and over, and over, by ranting about worthy Fallout titles. These two ideas, what I want from a Fallout game, and what you swear about as defining aspects of Fallout, they just have nothing to do with each other.
* I understand, and have not missed the point which you have painstakingly made with all the subtlety of a snow shovel, that you do not see a "Fallout FPS" as being worthy. It's just that I'm not that interested in discussing that, I'm not arguing with you about what "worthy" is, we've all got our differing opinions, and for the most part I think it'd be better if we cut down on the trying to ram them down each other's throats bit of proceedings.
Sander said:
No, what people are telling you over and over is that what *you* want from a Fallout game *would not be a Fallout game at all*.
In response to this, I would like to again respond by acknowledging the views of others. If what I want isn't a Fallout game in your eyes, or the eyes of others, great, you guys can skip calling it a "worthy" Fallout game. If it lives up to my expectations, I will call it a Fallout game, and that's a decision which I will happily make for myself. I don't understand why this continues to be such an issue.
Edit: Yes Dunneh, that's exactly what I'm saying, in just one or two sentences. I don't even understand how there is room to try to debate this. It seems painfully obvious to me, yet still, the attacks are coming? My enjoyment of a Fallout game doesn't hinge on what *anyone* else thinks is "worthy", it's really simple.