Maybe Fish is like me and has a soft spot for shitty games.
Speaking of soft spots, I replayed Arkham Origins; it’s the weakest entry in the series for sure, but it’s still fun, and it’s the only Arkham game that gets the “fear” aspect of Bamham’s persona right in my opinion. Enemies in Arkham Origins do not taunt you, they don’t go “I’m gonna break your face, Bat”, or call you chicken. Enemies in Arkham Origins are afraid. They’re fighting Batman because they think they’re going to die; in a weird way, setting the game near the beginning of his career allows for a better representation of how the thugs of Gotham see the Batman.
In addition, the game has my favorite Joker portrayal in a non-live action series next to John Doe from the Telltale games (yeah, I said it, Hamill isn’t my favorite). The scene where you watch him manipulate Harleen Quinzel is actually very well done, as is the rest of his characterization and dialogue, in my honest opinion.
All in all, on a scale from 1-10 with 5 being average, I give Arkham Origins a 7. Thé shock gloves are op, and the game is more linear than other Arkham games, but the boss fights are fun and the gameplay is classic Arkham and the story, while INCREDIBLY predictable, features an extremely underrated Joker portrayal and takes after the Frank Miller Batman more than the other games (with the characterization of Batman and the inclusion of SWAT Officer Branden, etc; Miller Batman is my favorite Batman, with The Dark Knight Returns and Year One being masterpieces in my eyes), which is definitely a positive thing.