Seriously? You can't imagine a Star Wars fan expressing the sentiment that it would be better if George Lucas had not made the prequel trilogy?
Right. I can't understand that. And I'm a starwars fan who watched the original when it first came out (which was when I was in elementary school) at least 10 times. And I still remember hearing the ads for it on the radio before it came out. Only radio ads from the 1970s that I can recall at all.
If we're going to play that game, he should have stopped at the first movie. The second two were pretty piss poor, and to be honest if it hadn't been for the record smashing success of the first movie I doubt anyone would have paid them much attention.
I guess I'm just not the type of person to feel I have more right to determine what an artist should do with his creation than the artist does.
And by the way, I'm a big Star Trek fan too, from way back. Not the kind who dresses up like a dork and goes to conventions, though... I'm the other kind who just watches the shows. Only conventions I ever went to were D&D ones back in the 1970s. And no I didn't dress up like a dork for those either, I just went. My friends dressed up like dorks but I don't think they did it on purpose. So anyway, I loved the hell out of Voyager. Deep Space 9 was blah. Next generation was blah. Enterprise was < blah. Should I hope that in order to honor the original series that no other Star Trek show is ever made? Nope, I can't relate to that. Some people actually liked those shows I called "blah" - they must have, because they ran for over 5 years. Who am I to say what is worthy of being made with the Star Trek name?
And by the way, Fallout 2 is just one of many great games that I'm a huge fan of. And I'm hugely disappointed nothing further was ever done with it, by the original team. But that doesn't mean I want the franchise to vanish for all time. That's been the fate of a lot of other games I used to love, and it doesn't make me feel any better than nobody (ever) did anything more with them.
The Dutch Ghost said:
What is the goddamn deal with you people that you want the majority of the board here to accept that Bethesda taking over the Fallout franchise was a good thing and that Fallout 3 is some kind of natural progression of the genre. (apologies in case I misunderstood it).
I don't know if you're talking about me, but for one thing I'm hardly a majority here! I'm not even a regular!
For what it's worth, my opinion is that the FO franchise died almost a decade ago when Interplay started mumbling about how they couldn't afford to devote resources to games like Fallout. I think Bethesda resurrected it - for their own selfish interests, of course. Two separate issues, for me.
I am in complete agreement with the rest of your post. And you said it better than I could
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f83c3/f83c3e6c026d78ada6e37712285c74afe2a904a1" alt="Smile :) :)"