A lot of the issues I had with the Outer Worlds have been mentioned already, but one thing I didn’t like about the game was that Phineas Welles didn’t actually have a plan to solve the food crisis. His plan was to just unfreeze all those colonists that had been left in cryo stasis and hope they’d be smart enough to figure it out. So essentially his solution to the food crisis is to increase the population...
Yep, that is also something I brought up earlier.
Phineas' solution was wake up scientists and engineers and expecting them to come up with a solution.
Well seeing what most people in the Halcyon system are like a group of trained and skilled specialists are probably more capable of solving the problem the colony suffers from.
Thing is is that they still need "time and room" to work with and with resources already diminishing.
Personally I am kind of disappointed that this was what the writers could come up with for a plotline. It feels very underwhelming and half thought out, especially after they have made it clear several times that Halcyon's food supplies are low.
Some sort of totalitarian government would have to be installed anyway to manage what food supplies and means of production there are as the board is corrupt and incompetent. They still focus on profit when the future of the colony is in question.
I really felt that some kind of twist was needed to make the story/main campaign better.
One idea I had was that it would be revealed that Phineas had been working on a better way of terraforming the planets and moons of the Halcyon system after the previous attempt/method proved to be ineffective.
Problem with his new approach is that it is going to kill everything organic on the current worlds in order to replace it with organisms that are more compatible with Terran life (think the Genesis device from Star Trek 2).
Now the board is not completely dismissing this solution to the crisis but Phineas feels that the colony got into trouble in the first place because of the board and the general incompetence of the colonists. He believes a complete restart is necessary and seeing as there is a starship full of scientists, technicians, and engineers out there who are still frozen he has come to the conclusion that they should be the founders of the new Halcyon colony. (perhaps Phineas even wants to establish a society based on intellectuals and philosopher kings).
The player would learn about what Phineas is really up to while looking for those chemicals, putting into question of the player is willing to help Phineas to commit genocide.
Likewise not everyone on the board would be incompetent and detached from reality, or there would be potential board members who are a lot saner which the player could get on the board that have more realistic solutions on solving the problems of the colony.
At the conclusion of the game still some sacrifices would have to be made and there would not be "one" good ending, rather just a number of different endings with the player having to choose which ones they can live the best with.