I usually fall in love instantly when it comes to games which capture a certain atmosphere quite well. But this here, hell, delivering a cinematic experience, yet you can free roam and it still doesnt get boring. When I started the game the first time, had goosebumps at the first time I could control my character... All those little details, the music (the best adaption of classical spaghetti soundtracks so far for me, dang I want to let my guitar sound like this
), everything delivers a really good atmosphere. The first time I encountered a simple storm in the game, how the horses react to the flash/thunder, how little water stains form after several time, the sheet lightning at the horizon up in the clouds...
Also, the beautiful landscape one can see when travelling from Mc Farlanes Ranch to Armadillo, this scenery, hell.. Or some minutes ago, I managed to cross the border to mexico, when first gaining control to the character, I was surprised: There was actually a song of Jose Gonzales playing! One of my favorite artists with the accoustic guitar... Just a new song of him in a new Rockstar title.
Awesome. It was the best moment so far for me ingame listening to this song and seeing those plains of mexico.
The general gameplay is also fun, the shooting is ok, though I find it a bit too easy, even without aim helps. Horse ridin' was a bit complicated at the beginning, but now I am used to the controls and it feels natural. The little jobs are also fun, though a bit too easy. The game could be a bit more hard in general imo. Also, the animal hunting, treasure hunting etc is motivatin as these things are fun. Looking forward for more in the game.