Here's my quickie, no-spoilers Fury Road review based on seeing it this afternoon:
It's no secret that I hated the trailer for Fury Road. In fact, the trailer is actually one of the reasons I decided I ought to see it: I had to reconcile my negative impressions with the good buzz the movie's been getting. And when I say good buzz, I don't mean the usual crony lickspittles who fawn over every pile of garbage the big studios churn out. I mean I see critics like A.O.Scott from the New York Times and Michael Phillips from the Chigaco Tribune - people who have some judgement - giving it good marks.
As I'm walking into the theater I'm thinking that, in order for me to like this movie, the trailer cannot have been representative of the whole. In other words, they would have had to put all the things I don't like in the trailer, and everything that isn't in the trailer would have to be pretty good.
As improbable as it seemed at the time, that's what happened.
I still hate the part where Max steps on the lizard. I think it's stupid. I'm not a fan of the guy leaping onto the car in slow motion. In fact, I don't like any of the slow motion bits in the movie. But actually there are only a couple of them and they're very short. They're not pervasive to the style. The guys sweeping back and forth on poles was far-fetched in the trailer and remains so in the movie, but that's not really a huge part of it either.
So, apart from all the stuff that was packed into the trailer, it's pretty good.
Saying Fury Road is better than the first two Mad Max movies is crazy talk. But does it have to be better? It's hardly an insult to say it's not.
It's difficult to compare those movies to this one, actually, because Fury Road is as different from the first three as The Road Warrior was from Mad Max. The whole feel of it is different for a bunch of reasons. Despite that, and unlike so many other late seqeuls and reboots, Fury Road manages to live up to its brand rather than being The Road Warrior's embarrassing bastard step-son. I think that's the most surprising thing about it.
It's success is mostly based on George Miller's bizarre imagery (the most bizarre of any in the series, and that's saying something) and his skill at directing action sequences.
So overall I liked it.