I'm going to be a spoil sport here, and point out that some of these comments are a little invalidated by the fact that they were either already present in the originals and beyond, or make perfect sense. It's a shit game nontheless, but some of these comments are a bit over-dramatic.
2: Ghouls don´t understand their own biology.
While the Kid in the Fridge quest is an abomination, that comment on its own is a bit nitpicky. Can you expect them to?, When most of them were born, there species didn't even exist yet.
13: Vertibirds are 3 seater dragons.
Don't quite get what this is supposed to mean.
18: Boston has 33 easy to obtain Power Armor Suits free for the taking.
To be fair, it is home to C.I.T, you'd expect it to be somewhat more technologically advanced than the rest of the world.
27: No one at Bethesda has ever played Fallout 2 (or probably any of the classics)
Emil and Todd specifically said that they played the originals. I think it's far more likely that Emil is a sellout, and Todd is too passive.
28: Magic exists because there's both enchanted weapons and enemies that can restore their health to full and start glowing after taking 2 bullets, known in some circles as "legendaries".
To be fair, there was a Ghost in Fallout 2. Magic was always established, just not as extremely
43: The female Sole Survivor, despite being a god damn lawyer can somehow hop right into power armor despite having no training…so does this mean power armor requiring training is retconed too?
Power Armor Training was introduced by Bethesda to begin with. In Fallout 1 you can basically just repair and get in a suit of PA just like that, In Fallout 2 you can basically just steal some from the Enclave and get in to it despite being a tribal with no knowledge of the world. I also don't see why people complain about this, as far as I'm aware Power Armor is just a fancy suit with Servos and Air Filters, apart from all the funny dials, why would it take too long to get used to that?
44: Robots can mutate, because reasons.
To be fair "Such and Such has Mutated" is just a line for legendary enemies when they get more powerful. I reckon that's just Beth being lazy, rather than them actually mutating, and really there just slightly more powerful than usual.
46: Every raider can make firearms from junk no matter how insane and illiterate they are.
It doesn't specify every raider can do that. Perhaps there is one craftsman per gang whose making a whole bunch of them. And besides, Fallout 1 raiders of all kinds could forge spears.
60. If you're really good at shooting raiders then you can develop the ability to breath underwater.
Pretty much every Fallout game has similar logic. EG. "I just killed a bunch of Deathclaws, now I suddenly know how to use a computer, and have a PHD in Chemistry" whenever you upgraded the Science skill.
64: A small, isolated group of scientists holed up underground can go on for over 200 years without inbreeding becoming an issue.
Not like any other Fallout game has had a small group of scientists holed up together for 200 years. *Cough Fallout 2* *Cough Enclave*
92. Atom must be the one true God in the Fallout universe since his followers can survive in the Ground Zero of a nuclear explosion despite rads spiking up to the 30s there with no protection whatsoever.
Theres a Fallout 2 Character who was kicked out of Vault City because he was immune to Radiation. Rad Immunities were cannon before FO4.
94: Turns out FEV was pretty common before the war. I mean, just look how prevalent it is throughout America! I bet you could buy canasters of it at your local Super Duper Mart.
To be fair, we've only seen 3 sources so far: Mariposa which makes sense because it's where it was first developed, Vault 87 which makes sense cause Vault-Tec were powerful, and The Institute which makes sense because of course a group of expert scientists would have access to all the cool toys.
104: Raiders, who are ordinary humans, can survive 20 bullets to the head and continue to fight!
Yeah, it's totally not like the originals followed the same logic.
109. The best way to create a deep and interesting companion, is to give them a silly accent.
And Black Isle Studios never did that?, *Cough Sulik *Cough. If anything, Sulik is even less deep.
124. You can buy a dog, get it sent somewhere, never water it, never even see it again, and it will be okay.
Like in every other Fallout game ever made.
125. Halloween decorations are not biodegradable and once stuck on something never come off.
Even the originals had old cardboard boxes and pieces of plastic lying around.
133. Temporary RadAway AIDS?
What does this mean?
at hurts me so much with how they degraded the FO series. But at the same time it's fucking hilarious.
So wait, if FO4 Vertibirds are like this, does this also apply to FO3 Vertibirds? (I wouldn't think it'd apply to NV vertibirds since there's only 2 in the whole game and they probably have their own AI)
I don't think using easy programming tricks is the same thing as degrading a series.
143 - German Sheperds are immortal and immune to radiation. But only after nuclear holocaust, thats a proven scientific fact.
There was a Husky in Fallout 1, and an Australian Shepherd in 1, 2 and 3. Purebred dogs are nothing new
Since Todd Howard is literally depicted as one of the most successful dictators of all history
Chris Avellone was presented as a badass bounty hunter in 1, and a mayor of a town in 2.
185. Apparently Mr. House must've been really clutzy with his COMMAND OVERRIDE CODES because Deacon somehow has the one for Mr. Handies and it actually briefly works on a Mr. Handy called Deezer. He claims he won it in a poker game.
Mr Handies are General Atomics International not RobCo, and the code doesn't even work.
187. Apparently the octopus population survived the nukes because there are going to be mutated octopi in Fart Harbor as well.
188. Apparently a blue ghoul whale exists somewhere in the ocean near Boston. Given the harpoon gun Fart Harbor's going to give us, it's only natural to assume we're going to hunt this thing Black Flag style.
And these things are bad because .....?
Well that's my work done.