snip
That is stupid. Me and the guys here were talking about what the plot could have been like if it has had some more focus on the synths, and one of the ideas we were playing with was the question of what if the player himself/herself was revealed to be a synth.
But you mention quite some points why that would not work such as the disease and radiation angle. What? The player is a special synth that is designed to be susceptible to these, a purposely build 'inferior' Generation 3 synth.
And how the hell would Shaun play into this.
We witness at the beginning of the game Shaun being kidnapped as a baby by Mr Cereal and the Institute, with the player's spouse being killed in front of the player's eyes.
If the player is a synth does that mean that both parents died? If so, how did Shaun get a copy of one his parents in the Vault to wake up there. And why would he do that? And if the player's memories are fake and non of the pre war history happened and he or she is not one of Shaun's real parents, why would Shaun have a synth made that believes that its one of his parents, have the synth brought to the Vault to wake up there, and then go on a search for Shaun? This would basically classify as retarded as one of Bethesda's Vault Experiments, but even more so.
What? Shaun likes to fuck around with the minds of synths for the lulz? I think that would probably make the rest of the Institute wonder who the hell they have as their leader if they weren't incompetent on their own.
Bethesda, you dug a hole, and now you are digging a deeper hole to get out.
If the player is a synth does that mean that both parents died? If so, how did Shaun get a copy of one his parents in the Vault to wake up there. And why would he do that? And if the player's memories are fake and non of the pre war history happened and he or she is not one of Shaun's real parents, why would Shaun have a synth made that believes that its one of his parents, have the synth brought to the Vault to wake up there, and then go on a search for Shaun? This would basically classify as retarded as one of Bethesda's Vault Experiments, but even more so.
What? Shaun likes to fuck around with the minds of synths for the lulz? I think that would probably make the rest of the Institute wonder who the hell they have as their leader if they weren't incompetent on their own.
Bethesda, you dug a hole, and now you are digging a deeper hole to get out.