Remember that list we all agreed on? SuAside still mentions it in his sig:
FO3 needs: Isometric view (3D will do)/SPECIAL/non-linear story/turn-based combat/versatile quests/dialog trees
Now, I don't know about the versatile quests and dialogue trees, but so far only SPECIAL seems to have survived (minus Traits or so it seems).
They've also started to mess with the setting (e.g. PipBoy 3000 has been combined with a character creation screen showing a Vault Boy, supermutants that look like orcs à la Lord Of The Rings, handheld nuclear catapults, ...).
I was hopeful after seeing the teaser trailer, and could have lived with a different kind of Power Armour, but after reading the article and seeing the screenshots, I'm wondering why we still bother.
Soon we'll have 2 brilliant old-school games, a sweet tech-demo of a very promising yet cancelled sequel, 3 miserably failed attempts to revive the franchise and a dozen or so unfinished mods.
Wow. If Fallout were a rockband, the bandmembers would now be smoking crack and contemplating suicide.
One of the saddest things, IMHO, is this: Bethesda had a chance to reach out to all those gamers who have been (im)patiently waiting for a new TB isometric game worthy of playing. There's a market out there for games like that. And the Fallout franchise offered a chance to explore that market. And what do they do? They go FPS action-RPG. How stupid can you get? Instead of exploring a 'new' market, they aim for the herd. The console herd, in the first place. PC-gamers will be stuck with a lousy conversion of a lousy sequel of one of the best PC-games ever.
I could have lived with a FPS Fallout 3. That is, if they would have respected the setting. It would have been a chance to experience the Fallout universe in a different way. Like C&C Renegade, so to speak. I'd put on my blue spandex and go hunting for green mutants that look like something out of a 50's B-movie. Now it seems I'll have to jump into my designer Vaultsuit and shoot Doom 3 demons with my handheld nuclear catapult. And they'll wield hammers that look like they were freshly forged in Dante's hell. And I'll probably have to remain in Washington DC, cleaning the sewers and the underground. I can probably forget about those versatile quests then.
Pfff...
It feels so good to be a Fallout fan, doesn't it? You have nothing to look forward to except disappointment.