What is your favorite Deus Ex game

Which Deus Ex game is your favorite?

  • Deus Ex: Invisible War

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Deus Ex: Human Revolution

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    116

The Dutch Ghost

Grouchy old man of NMA
Moderator
* warning, some spoilers *



Hello all,

Now that I have finished Deus Ex Human Revolution I can compare my thoughts on it and how it compares to the previous games.

Graphically the game looked very nice and the level in detail is great even though some people are complaining that the graphics are not as good as that as other popular games on the moment but I find that a moot point and honestly not that important.

In general this game felt a lot more like Deus Ex 1 than Invisible War did, not as streamlined and made more into an FPS.
Surprisingly I found Jensen even weaker than JC Denton when it came to combat, even with all the armor upgrades

Most likely done to put more emphasis on stealth and hiding behind cover during fighting.
The cover system was not as detracting as I feared it would be, feeling like a console thing.

Still I found it a bit of a shame that skills and augmentations were almost still completely the same thing as in Invisible War, rather than that skills like hacking and fire arms were separate from augmentations which were more like special abilities.
I still prefer the DE1 system.

Story wise the game was pretty good but I can not help but feeling that the whole augmentation issue was kind of a repeat of the Knights Templar sub story from IW.

It was more of a open political issue now rather than the issue of nano augmentation, with people more openly debating it and being divided in various camps about it.

Plus it was also more visible rather than nano augmentations which only a select few people had, making the debate issue a bit more complex.

Still, to be honest I did not find the story as strong as the first Deus Ex.
It could be that nostalgic memories are influencing my judgment but I found the setup, the background, and the conspiracy mysteries more stronger in tune with popular culture,

While I like the graphics and the details a lot, I sadly have a bit of an issue with the looks.
They are not bad and that is not the problem, but they are way to futuristic compared to DE1 which seemed more closer to our present but still felt more natural advanced.

There was really high tech technology such as robots, the computers, energy weapons, and cities were a bit more advanced but there were still present day 'roots', like for example passenger planes, ships, and helicopters.

Technology, cities and dress styles looked way more futuristic in Human Revolution, making me wonder what could have happened that changed this deliberate renaissance like look that the world seemed to be going through, and make it decay into the near present and yet further in the future DE1.

Shanghai was basically one city on top of another, and while I can understand that a recession could stop that from happening with for example Hong Kong, Hong Kong or the other cities in DE1 did not show any signs that architecture had advanced that far before things slowed down.

I can understand that this comes down as artistic interpretation, with the old development team having a different vision than the new one, but this creates a type of inconsistency.
To me DE HR seems more advanced than DE1, and if we did not know of the time period and the augmentation technology, would make more sense taking place behind DE1 rather than before it.

Sorry for the long rant, what I would like to ask people reading this topic and who have perhaps played DE1 in the past to tell what their favorite DE game is.

While I really like Deus Ex Human Revolution, recuperating the franchise from the blow it took with Invisible War, IMO Deus Ex 1 is still my favorite of the franchise.
It may look rather outdated, I still find this game regarding its controls and story better.
Now if only they could add the grenade throwing button to it.
 
I have to say, I like HR the best so far.


It has all the things I liked from Deus Ex (tech noir story, lotta cool sci fi) but with less of that dumb conspiracy stuff
 
Sabirah said:
I have to say, I like HR the best so far.


It has all the things I liked from Deus Ex (tech noir story, lotta cool sci fi) but with less of that dumb conspiracy stuff

But that is one of the core points of Deus Ex.
Its like saying that you like Fallout but would prefer less of the 50's retro future stuff.
 
I am liking Deus Ex Human revolution a lot, I feel the AI of the enemies is better than the one from the first game, it sucks that there is no real Melee combat other than the takedowns though.
 
Well, its kind of hard to compare all these games, given that they are from different eras and games as general have progressed and are doing a lot of stuff better now (and some stuff worse).

So, all that technical stuff aside, I liked Human Revolution, it is a good, but not stellar game.
I really like the dialogue system in it. The choices are not as good as in Alpha Protocol, but the whole wandering around thing makes it a lot more lifelike. Its surprising how such a small thing changes the whole experience. Also, even without the social enhancement (which you should really only get in the second playthrough), you can really feel the reactions of the people. But this, again, is a technical thing, that wasn't possible back in DE 1 days. However, I feel that the writing is a lot better too. Jensen always sounds like a very smart an empathic guy, I really like that. So +1 for HR.

The story, on the other hand was quite weak. The timing of a lot of surprises and twists wasn't that good. I really liked the one in DE1 better.

This really IS a spoiler, in the way that it reveals the whole story, sure you want to click it?
[spoiler:670e8bc17e]One of the major twists is given away in the INTRO of the game.. wtf?

Also, the biochip-upgrade-thing is not very well timed. At the time it happened, Im pretty sure most players knew something fishy was going on. It just fit to well into all of the other events. The revelation would work a lot better if the upgrade happened in earlier stages of the game, like the first time in Detroit. This would also make the illuminati look a lot more ingenious.

Also, I knew right in the beginning of the game that Reed took my DNA. I think everybody knows after they visited LIMB the first time. Again, this could have worked if timed differently, AFTER the player finds out that Jensen was the result of an experiment.
But I don't understand the whole point anyhow. Yeah she took my DNA to make life of a lot of people better - SO WHAT? Whats the deal with that? Why didn't she just said: "whoa dude, your DNA is awesome, can we use it?". Its like someone would approach me like "hey, the cure for cancer and aids is in your genes, mind if we use it to cure a couple of diseases?". What kind of sick bastard says no to that? Yeah sure, she should have told us, but why didn't she in the first place? There is no reason for that.

Also, why did they reveal Zhao as an illuminati right away? THE FIRST TIME WE MEET HER? The illuminati, greatest minds of history would be capable to make it seem like she was really not a part of them. This could have been a nice surprise for the player.[/spoiler:670e8bc17e]

The next thing, where are the big choices? DeusEx 1 was a lot better in that regard, too. There was also more feedback on what you did. There is, as far as I know, only one time in HR where that happens, right after the first assignment.

Gameplaywise, I really like HR. You always have a lot of choices what to do, even if they are a little bit TO obvious sometimes. You can always choose to fight or talk or sneak your way in, and thats great. I have only played it through one time right now, so I don't know if the feeling is really that different if you go for a more aggressive strategy instead of sneaking but currently, I feel it would. If so, this is great and it may very well be one of the greatest games in that regard. The only thing I don't like about HR are the bossfights. Not because there ARE bossfights, I am completely ok with that, but they seem so imbalanced. For a sneaky character, the first two bossfights are almost impossible to pull off. The third one was pretty easy, because I had full armor and a couple of weapons that actually can kill people.

So overall, I like the first game a little bit better, just because of the story. HR is still a very good game, and one you can buy full price without regret.
 
The Dutch Ghost said:
Sabirah said:
I have to say, I like HR the best so far.


It has all the things I liked from Deus Ex (tech noir story, lotta cool sci fi) but with less of that dumb conspiracy stuff

But that is one of the core points of Deus Ex.
Its like saying that you like Fallout but would prefer less of the 50's retro future stuff.

And that's why I didn't like DX as much as a lot of people seemed to.

To me Deus Ex was perfect (especially when that AI contacted you in the prison) until you met the Illuminati. At that point the game went downhill especially after the part where you break into the lab in china
 
Yeah they should never have used something as lame as the Illuminati.
You have a world ruled by mega corporations and they still throw in teh evil Illuminati.

Made me frown when I played Deus Ex and it made me frown again a couple of days ago when they were first mentioned in HR.
So lame.


The game itself is pretty damned good but I haven't finished it yet.
 
After finishing Human Revolution today, I have to say that I really liked it. Not sure if I like it as much as Deus Ex, but it was still pretty damn good for what it's worth. Now, Invisible War on the other hand - console tripe, at least with Human Revolution they made an effort for a PC version and not just a console port.

I will say one thing though, I enjoyed Invisible War a hell of a lot more than Thief: Deadly Shadows (made by the same guys, comparisons between the two are made everywhere). While unrelated I just thought I'd mention it as everyone seems to think otherwise.

Walpknut said:
I feel the AI of the enemies is better than the one from the first game
That really should go without saying.
 
Sabirah said:
I have to say, I like HR the best so far.


It has all the things I liked from Deus Ex (tech noir story, lotta cool sci fi) but with less of that dumb conspiracy stuff

You pretty clearly didn't pay attention in the opening cutscene, did you? how far into the game are you?

DX:HR basically took everything MGS4 did wrong and made it right. There's still some mininum shittiness factor (boss fights, batteries being a pain in the ass to recharge, merchants only being worth visiting once, stealth play throughs being far more lucrative in terms of EXP while not being all that difficult, etc).
 
THE question, eh? Deus Ex or Human Revolution?

Well, visually HR blows it's ancestor out of the water. Not only from the obvious HD graphics, but also thanks to the superb and, most importantly, consistent art direction. It does look a bit too futuristic at times (mostly Hengsha, I mean, two cities on top of each other must be one hell of a feat of engineering), but it's easily excusable to me. IIRC Warren Specter himself said it was OK. Deus Ex lacked that impactful visual design, too many gray areas and stuff ripped straight out other IPs (grey aliens, MIBs...).

Audio, well the voice acting is simply better this time around (remember those horrible Asian and French accents? the pain...), and the music is very good too. Nothing to match Deus Ex's menu theme, sadly, but as a package HR is a bit better on this front.

Story wise, even if the first game has some flaws and plot holes, it's still better than HR. The latter's big huge twist was guessed by me close to the beginning, and a certain comment made by a certain character pretty much confirmed my theory, as I found out a couple of hours later. HR also didn't use it's themes to it's fullest potential; augmentation debates were a bit reduced to haves vs have-nots (read, economical considerations), while the psychological (not enough self-doubt, or at least possibilities of it, on Jensen's part imo), practical (augmented workers vs ''normals''), and political (politician using CASIE augs to gain advantage in a debate or somesuch) issues were barely touched. Also, [spoiler:7756d9cc97]too much AIs already in the timeline. Eliza being one was a bit unnecessary to me. Hyron was neat, however.[/spoiler:7756d9cc97]. That said, I liked the fact HR was more grounded and actual (riots, need I say more?) for the most part, rather than go full-on conspiracy kitchen sink corporations-and-governments-want-to-kill-us.

Gameplay wise, it's a bit complicated. Deus Ex is better on paper; skills + Augs make for a better progression than Augs alone, having to choose which Aug adds more choices, ect. In practice, HR is better; there seems to be more possible paths, even if the areas are smaller; shoot stuff, sneak by, hack, use vents, move heavy stuff, punch through walls, survive falls by Icarus aug, jump up, pile up crates, talk your way in, some levels allow you to do ALL of this, while the first game seemed to have 2, max 3 possibilities per level, I may be wrong however it's been a few years. Weapon progression extends to non-lethal in HR too, something I enjoyed greatly after being stuck with a friggin prod for all the first game long (the PEPS is the best, coolest weapon in the game imo, and it's not lethal). Set pieces are rarely used, but are when they are they're well done [spoiler:7756d9cc97](most notably the frenzied rush to save Malik's life, or defending the elevator in Montreal with mah beloved gas mines)[/spoiler:7756d9cc97], the AI is better and sneaking requires more skill/timing and less luck.

Characters, it's a bit of a tie. Page is the most memorable villain and I liked Denton more than Jensen even with (or maybe because of?) his cheesier writing and voice acting. But HR's supporting cast was better, Malik was nice and Sarif seemed like a conflicted, believable character, not a cliche, full of himself mega-billionaire.

Boss fights, eh, Barrett was a bit of a pain, until I found out about EMP grenades. That's it, big boy, stand still and let papa Adam riddle your skull with 10mm rounds. [spoiler:7756d9cc97]Fedorova][/spoiler:7756d9cc97] was better, and [spoiler:7756d9cc97]Namir[/spoiler:7756d9cc97] I found to be a bit too easy, while [spoiler:7756d9cc97]Hyron[/spoiler:7756d9cc97] was pretty good. Basically, every boss was made much easier by copious use of EMP grenades.

Final verdict? I still don't know. I will have to replay HR to decide, replay value will probably break the tie. But Eidos Montréal's effort has a slight advantage so far. Damn good game.
 
well at least one can see Human Revolution as Deus Ex.

Its not so bad like the jump from Fallout 1/2 to Fallout 3 ...

I guess we can not expect today that modern sequels to past games really create the same feeling (not that this is really possible I am just saying). At least one has to appreciate the try here. I think they did their best. What more can we expect today ?
 
You guys don't use spoilers enough. If I hadn't already beaten the game (courtesy of Irene) I'd be fucking pissed at you guys. the SA thread read like a redacted CIA document, especially considering that spoilers o there are black boxes.

That said, I haven't played DE one yet (Yes I know I'm a horrible person), but I really liked the art of HR since most of what was futuristicy was stuff related to augments or "new" stuff, and other than the odd hologram (which I didn't care for), it was all pretty cool and consistent.

The boss battles: [spoiler:4f08cd4e12]Were all in all pretty gay. I dunno how I"m gonna handle them this go round since I'm only carrying a stun gun and a 10mm pistol as of right now. I might drop the pistol and pick up a combat rifle instead just so I can blast the bosses in the head. Or lots of grenades, since that's how I beat Namir or whatever his name was. Don't need augs to throw grenades at your face, do I, jerkface.

That fight was the best one, IMO. Mostly because I had gotten the LIMB chip. The last boss fight was kinda "Eh", mostly cause I didn't have a clue as to what you're supposed to do and you can't say, pull the chicks out and help them.[/spoiler:4f08cd4e12].

On Hengsha:
[spoiler:4f08cd4e12]Lower hengsha was totally awesome, upper hengsha was HELLO THE FACT THAT WE WERE BOUGHT BY THE PEOPLE WHO MADE FINAL FANTASY SEVEN IS NOT APPARENT.[/spoiler:4f08cd4e12].

And on Eliza
[spoiler:4f08cd4e12]Thought the she was a random AI was really dumb. I really liked how the AI of the Hyron project was controlled by people/with people was a lot more of an interesting way to have an AI. Her being a bigass computer was bland by comparison. Hell, if she was a bigass computer with the actual Eliza inside it would've been more interesting and foreshadowing and showing what the Illuminati can do.

OH and the fact that Picus just replays the same thirty second interview clip is so fucking annoying I cannot stand. YES I UNDERSTAND SHUT UP NOW PEWPEW BYE BYE TELEVISION.
[/spoiler:4f08cd4e12]

And the end game
[spoiler:4f08cd4e12]Zombies were fucking dumb. So fucking dumb.[/spoiler:4f08cd4e12].
 
Wintermind said:
You guys don't use spoilers enough. If I hadn't already beaten the game (courtesy of Irene) I'd be fucking pissed at you guys.

Well I'm glad I skipped over every post then.

Anyway, nothing will ever beat the original...at least in my mind. That said, aside from the fucking sheer inanity of the boss fights and my near-fist-through-the-wall frustration with them, I am very impressed with and stoked about this game. I'm only about half-way through Heng-Sha and I feel like I've been feasting.
 
so you would recommend it to a "deus ex" fan ? Because I am somewhat not yet sure if I will buy it ... Many say its "alright" but I have the feeling I might buy it and suddenly run in something I absolutely hate or which will completely disappoint me. Like the ending. Or some "console shit" (controls or what ever ...).

Just saying. I really would love to buy it. But I am a bit short on money. So its either Deus Ex or the Witcher 2. But TW2 is kinda cheap right now.
 
Crni Vuk said:
so you would recommend it to a "deus ex" fan ? Because I am somewhat not yet sure if I will buy it ... Many say its "alright" but I have the feeling I might buy it and suddenly run in something I absolutely hate or which will completely disappoint me. Like the ending. Or some "console shit" (controls or what ever ...).

Just saying. I really would love to buy it. But I am a bit short on money. So its either Deus Ex or the Witcher 2. But TW2 is kinda cheap right now.

I find this one difficult to answer as the game has good points but also had some flaws like the lack of a third city hub which would have been nice and the last part of the game which was rather a let down.

Let me say it this way, I myself finished the game in 29 hours, if Witcher 2 is longer I suggest that one instead.
 
Read the GameBanshee review, Crni. It says all you need to know. Also: What TDG just said about DE:HR is exactly how I felt about TW2. So, horse a piece I guess.

My vote goes to Deus Ex.
 
Let me say it this way, I myself finished the game in 29 hours, if Witcher 2 is longer I suggest that one instead.

TW2 is about the same if you do one play-through, but you really need two if you want to cover all of the game content.
 
Ausdoerrt said:
TW2 is about the same if you do one play-through, but you really need two if you want to cover all of the game content.

Then I don't really know what to advice either.
In the past, what game did you like slightly more? Deus Ex, or The Witcher 1?

Otherwise we do the old parent-child-in-a-store bit.
You are holding The Witcher 2 and Deus Ex Human Revolution in your hands, I give you ten seconds to decide which one you want the most, if the ten second are over and you still have not be able to decide you don't get either.
 
Back
Top